A DIGEST
CANADIAN CASES
RAILWAY, TELEGRAPH, TELEPHONE
AND EXPRESS COMPANIES
Being a Digest of "Canadian Railway Cases," Yob.
1 to 24, together with decisions of the Federal and
Provincial Courts of Canada, the Judicial Committee
of the Privy Council on appeal therefrom, the Board
of Railway Commissioners for Canada, and Provincial
Boards, up to the end of the year 1919.
CROSS REFERENCED AND ANNOTATED
A. H. O'BRIEN
Barrister-at-Law
Late Law Clerk of the House of Commons of Canada;
Author of "O'Brien's Conveyancer."
TORONTO:
CANADA LAW BOOK COMPANY, LIMITED
M BAY STREET
1920
Copyright, Canada, 1920, by R. R. CBOMARTT, TORONTO.
EXPLANATIONS.
"Board" and "Railway Board" The Board of Railway
Commissioners for Canada, established 1903.
"Railway Committee" The Railway Committee of the
Privy Council of Canada, which was superseded, in 1903,
by the Board of Railway Commissioners for Canada.
"Privy Council" Judicial Committee of the Privy Coun-
cil (Imperial) sitting in London, England. the final Court
of Appeal in Canadian cases.
"B.NJL Act" British North America Act, 1867 (Im-
perial).
"LC.R." Intercolonial Railway of Canada (Dominion
Government Railway System).
"CJL Dig." Canadian Annual Digest of the year which
follows.
"(D)" Statute of Dominion of Canada.
"The Railway Acf ' The Railway Act of Canada of the
year which follows.
RAILWAY ACTS.
The following are the General Railway Acts of Canada,
in chronological order, up to March 1st, 1920:
1851 (14-15 Viet.), c. 51, "The Railway Clauses Consoli-
dation Act"
1859 (Consolidated Statutes of Canada), c. 66, "The
Railway Act"
1868 (31 Viet), c. 68, "The Railway Act"
1879 (42 Viet), c. 9, "The Consolidated Railway Act,
1879."
1886 (Revised Statutes of Canada), c. 109, "The Rail-
way Act"
1888 (51 Viet), c, 29, "The Railway Act"
1903 (3 Edw. Vn.), c. 58, "The Railway Act"
1906 (R. S. C.), c. 37, "The Railway Act"
1919 (9-10 Geo. V.), c, 68. "The Railway Act"
in
416320
CASES
AM-Aai.] GMaaam. Aad-Att-] Cohnaa,
Abdoa T. CPJL Co. 513 Aadnas T. CJPJL Co. .. 172.
Ahrer T. CJP.R. Co. 3SC 173,193,4381537
Artoa Taaaiag Co. T. Toraa- Aadrews T. B.C. Efcr. RT. Co. 9S-
to Cahaibaa RT. Co. 332 Aagas T. School Trustees of
Adolph Linker Co. T. "Great -Cai*ary 33
NortWra RT. Co. .. 737 Aataja T. Wabash RT. Co. ... 113
Aheara 4 Soper T. Nev York Araushav T. B.C. Eke. RT. Co. 722
Trast Co. - 1633 AraMroag r. Caaada Attaatk-
Aiaslie lOaia* 4 RT. Co. T. RT. Co. 23$. 239. 23$
MrD*a*aIl " 234 - T. C.X JR. Co. 9*. 2*M
Alberta Railway Act. Re ... 154 Arat*Hroagr Cartage Co. T. G.
fclU Traia Serriee Case .. 813 T.R. Co. 5*4
Alberta Vailed FaraHrs T. C. Aratstnoa^ aad Jaaws Bay RT.
Pi. C*. 731 COL. Re ..MS, 374
ATaia T. C.PJK. Co. 332 Aravstroag T. McGihboa 4<
Albo T. Great Nortbera Ry. Arthar T. Ceatral Uatario RT.
Co. 92 Co. 44)1
Alfred T. G.T JP JL Co. ..... 14. 15 Asrher T. G.T.R. Co. ...".'."..'. SO
- T. CLT.P.R. Co. 12 Aseott T. i oatptoa I9
Ceatral 4 Hadna Bay iahiff T. CA'.K. Co. 114
Ry. Co. T. G-T-R. Co. AAlaad ATCBOP CrossiB; Ca- 4<c
7^9. 790 Assesfant Apprak* Toroato
Ceatral Ry. Co. T. The Ry. Co_ Re 34
Kiag ..." 197 Asgaiboia T. C.NJL Co. ...<#.
Aksaader T. CJ.R. Co. 314 473, 393
AEaa T. G.T.R. Co. 247 Atehesaai T. G.T.R. Co. 72
ABn T. C.P.R. Co. 525, 52S Atikokaa Iroa Co. T. CJPJL
" T. Graad Taller Ry. Co. Co.. 813
13*. 227 Atkia T. C.P.R. Co. 404
* T. Great Westera Ry. Co. 89 Atkiasoa T. G.TJL Co 332
Ahaoatf Kafttiag Co. " Case, Atkiasoa T. Taaeoarcr. Tie-
Re 744 toria 4 Eastera Ry.
Abacwte Kaittiap Co. T. C. P. Co. ! . 815
R. Co. ete. (Abaoate Atiaatie 4 Lake Saperior RT.
Kahtiig Co. Case.. 744 Co, Re .". 4S<
AanhjaaMtioa AgreeawatSy Re ~ T. De GaKadez 51
5, 599 Atiaatie 4 Nonh-West. Ry.
Aawricaa Coal 4 Coke Co. T. Co. r. Jodah ... 29S
Mkhisu Ceatral Ry. Attoraey Geanl for Alberta
Co. .. .. 59S, SIC T - Attoraey Gaeral
Aaiyot T. Qaetev RyC Light 4 <^fi - 1*
Pom rL* aa Attoraey Geaeral for British
Herator 4 Wario.^ " Cohbi, ^ T C ^J^R _C*.
imr -4f Ct*L T C X R 144 - i * S - * ai i<M
IS S?V R " T Ta^twrer. Tktoria,
Eastera. ete Cou 14-
lad BeH Telephoae Attoraer Gnwnl for Caaada
Lo ^ * - " r. S*a adard Trost C-
AadersoaT. C^fJLCo. .. 243. ^of New York 7
^^^" '"-* V, \^UfVf^ <t ocUflKBAT' KT.
T. Toroato. lTailt^ 4 Co. 1
Buffalo Ry. Co. Anoraey Oaerai for ibaitoba
CFarai Crossrags " T. Wnvipe^ Eler. Rr.
Caae) 374 Co. C84, CBS
T
VI
CASES DIGESTED.
Att-Bea.] Column.
Attorney General for Ontario
v. Hamilton Street
Ry. Co 151
Atwood v. Kettle River Valley
Ry. Co 362
Auger v. Can. Northern Que-
bec Ry. Co 46
" v. G.T.R. and C.P.R. Cos.
597, 753, 803
Average Demurrage Case 220
Aylmer Condensed Milk Co. v.
American Express Co. 774
Baker Reynolds & Co. v. C.P.R.
Co 746
Bacon v. G.T.R. Co 401
Baggage Car Traffic Rules, Re 45
Baie des Chaleurs Ry., Re 487
Rain v. C.P.R. Co 419
Baird v. C.P.R. Co 856
Barnhill v. Hampton & Saint
Martins Ry. Co 51
Balfour v. Toronto Ry. Co.
f>62, 701
Balgonie Protestant Public
School District v. C.P.
R. Co 37
Ball v. Sydney & Louisberg Ry.
Co 385
" v. Wabash Ry. Co 572
Banbury v. Regina . 707
Bank of Montreal v. Kirkpat-
rick 035
Bank Street Subway Case . . . 476
Banff Livery & Busmen v. C.P.
R, Co 649, 650
Bannatyne v. Suburban Rapid
Transit Co 341
Banque see Bank.
Bardgett v. C.P.R. Co 408
Baril v. G.T.R. Co 358
Barker v. Pollock 113
Barnett v. G.T.R. Co 120, 121
Barr v. Toronto Ry. Co. and
Toronto 710
Barrett v. C.P.R. Co 34!), 845
Bartlett v. Winnipeg Elec. Ry.
Co. and C.N.R. Co. ... 534
Basanta v. C.P.R. Co 237
Bate and Ottawa, Re 028
Bate v. C.P.R. Co 523, 531
Battle Creek Toasted Corn
Flake Co. v. Canadian
Freight Assn 806
Bay of Quinte Ry. Co. v.
Kingston & Pembroke
Ry. Co 584
Bayly v. Bell Telephone Co. . . 829
Beal v. Michigan Central Ry.
Co 12, 421
Beaton v. Mabou & Gulf Ry.
Co. 321
Bea-Bil.] Column.
Beaudet v. North Shore Ry.
Co 297
Bechtel v. C.P.R. Co 273
Beck v. C.N.R. Co 71
Becker v. C.P.R. Co 402
Begin v. The King 439
Belanger v. The King 4:5!)
Bell v. Inverness Coal & Ry.
Co 238, 272
" v. Cape Breton Elec. Co. 671
" v. G.T.R. Co 174, 186
" v. Winnipeg Elec. Street
Ry. Co 712
Bell Telephone Co. v. Chatham 853
" v. C.P.R. Co., G.T.R. Co.
and Toronto ( Brock
Avenue Subway Case) 855
" v. Falkirk Telephone Co. 730
" v. London 732
" v. Xipissing Power Co. . . 854
" v. Ottawa and Carleton .. 731
" v. Windsor 731
" v. Windsor, Essex & Lake
Shore Rapid Ry. Co. 854
" v. Zarbatany 732
Belleville Interchange Tracks,
Re 492
Bennett v. G.T.R. Co 546
Bennetto v. C.P.R. Co 321
Benning v. Atlantic & N.W.
Ry. Co 315
Berliner Gramophone Co. v.
Canadian Freight
Assn 750
Berlinquet v. The Queen 430
Berlin & Waterloo Street Ry.
Co. v. Berlin .* . 682
Bertram v. Hamilton & Dundas
Street Ry. Co 56
Bessette v. C.P.R. Co 601
Beverly Coal Mine and Hum-
berstone Coal Cos. v.
G.T.P.R. Co 62
Bickerdike v. Can. Northern
Montreal Tunnel &
Terminal Co 217
Bickford v. Canada Southern
Ry. Co 158
" v. Chatham 618
" v. Grand .Junction Ry. Co. 46
Bickerdike v. Montreal Park &
Island Ry. Co 22
Biddeson v. C.N.R. Co 391
Bienfait Commercial Co. v. C.
P.R. Co 62
Biggs v. G.T.R. Co 15
Bigaouette v. North Shore Ry.
Co 336
Billings and Can. Northern On-
tario Ry. Co., Re 328, 329
Billings v. Gloucester, Re.... 629
CASES DIGESTED. vii
80 Bra.] Column. Bra-BrL] Column.
Billington T. Hamilton Street Brant Milling: Co. T. G.T.R.
Ry. Co. 718 Co. Brant MiBing
Birch Avenue Extension Case 358 Cos. Case) 744
Bird T. C-P JL Co. . . 195, 458, 5OO Brantford T. G.TJL Co. . . 47O.
Black T. Calgary 7O7 480,481
- T. Canadian Express Co. 103 " T. Grand Valley Ry. Co.
- T. Winnipeg Eke. Ry. Co. 683 ' 660. 661
Blackwood T. C.N.R. Co. ' 364 Brantford Golf * Country Club
Blackwoods, etc. T. C.NJR- Co. 59 and Lake Erie i
Blain T. CJPJL Co. 117 Northern Ry. COL. Re 335
Bmis T. G.T.R. Co. 848 Brantford. Waterloo 4 Lake
Blakely T. Montreal Tramways Erie RT. Co. T. Huff-
Co. "..722 man .". 159
Blangas Co. T. Canadian Brampton Commutation Case
Freight Assn 74 821. S22
Blind River Board of Trade v. Brampton T. G.T. and CJ.
G. T. etc- Cos. 888 R. Cos. (Brampton
Block v. Can. Northern Pacific Interchange Case* .. 814
Ry. Co. 410 Brampton Interchange Case . . 814
Blue T. Red Mountain Ry. Co. Brampton Milling Co. T. C-P.
417, 418 R. Co. SIC
Brrth T. McKiliop 733 Brawler T. Toronto Ry. Co. . . 710
Boards of Trade of Gait. etc. Brazeau T. C-P.R. ..." 1*5
T. Grand Trunk. Can. Brenner v. Toronto Ry. Co.
Pac_ etc., Ry. Co>- 562. 690. 691
490. 584 Brewer T. Lake Erie i Detroit
Boards of Trade of Montreal River Ry. Co. 557
and Toronto T. Canadian Bridgebury v. G.T. and Mkh-
Assn. 598. 810 igan Central Ry. Cos.
BUM ill of Trade of Western 68. 473
Cities and Canadian Bkffl T. G.T.R. Co. 79. 94
Manufacturers' Assn. Brillant T. The King 440
T. Canadian Freight British American Oil Co. T. C.
An 810 P-R- Co. 796
Bogard T. King 35 ^ T. G.TJL Co.
Boland v. G.T.R. Co. . 88 British Canadian Canners v. G.
Boldnc T' CP-R- Col .'.'.'. 373, 496 T JL Co. ....
Bole Grain Co. T. C.P.R. Co. .. 100 *<"**** *"?**"?* Ml !?V
Bondy T. Sandwich. Windsor * *? P ** M *-^ 1 -,
Amherstburg Ry. Co. 724
Boners' Ferry Lumber Co. T. *""** p^^X^^TV
. - ... A- ranner? insuunes T.
Great Northern RT. Co. .. 9a < v & t -*#
_ r,^- n f- " i fl? *- - - *-*- **-
2** T ' ,^ ~ - British Columbia Eke. RT. Co.
Booth T. CJJL Co. a!8 T. Gapton 5O5
Bouchard T. Quebec Ry. Light ^ Gentik 543
4 Power Co. T. Loach 539
Boultoa T. Peterborough 63O - T Stewart 653. 660
Bourassa T. C-P.R. Co. 4O2 -T.Turner 503. .>43
Bouton T. CJ-R- Co. . .156 v Vancouver, etc. . . 147.
Bowie T. Buffalo. Brantford ft 4^^ 595 5^5
Goderich Ry. Co. 81 T . Wilkinson .'270
Bowlby T. HaUiax * South BritUh Colmilku Xews (^ T
^fff Rv . Co - ?i; Express Traffic Assn. >7
{S^bu^^OtS^Ek^^ ' ^ish C|b7a P^c Coa.
RT. Co. ... 303 Cl0es - C - P
Branch Lines CJJL, Re 55 (VaneouTer Intenor
BrMiim Shipper T. OP. and ^J*2- t5S
G.TJJL Cos. 492 British Columbia Railway Act
Brant T. C.PJL Co. .." 1 ..... 216 d Can. Northern Pa-
Brant Milling Cos. Cue, Re.. 744 eific Ry. Co., Re 313
Vlll
CASES DIGESTED.
Bri-Byr.] Column.
British Columbia Sugar Refin-
ing Co. v. C.P.R. Co.
772, 805
Brochu v. The King 447
Brock v. Toronto & Nipissing
Ry. Co 624
Brock Avenue Subway Case . . 855
Brockville v. Sherwood 030
Brook v. C.P.R. Co. . 407
Brotherhood of Locomotive En-
gineers, Re 253, 587
Brown v. C.P.R. and C.N.R.
Cos 128
Brulott v. G.T.P.R. Co 244
Brown v. G.T.R. Co 212, 248
" v. London Street Ry. Co. 561
" v. Moose Jaw Elec. Co. . . 711
" v. Quebec & Lake St. John
Ry. Co 825
Brown Milling & Elevator Co.
v. C.P.R. Co 322
Brunelle v. G.T.R. Co 564
Brussels v. McKillop Telephone
System 733
Buckland v. C.X.R. Co 70
Bugg v. C.X.R. Co 408
Burkholder v. G.T.R. Co 20!)
Burlington Beach Commission
v. Hamilton Radial
Elec. Ry. Co 844, 777
Burlington Beach Case, Re 5!)8, 842
Burnaby v. British Columbia
Elec. Ry. Co. ... 486, 060
Burns v. Toronto Ry. Co 223
Burnt District Case, Toronto,
No. 25 318, 320
Burman v. Ottawa Elec. Ry.
Co 717
Burrard Inlet Tunnel & Bridge
Co., Re 576, 594, 641
Burriss v. Pere Marquette Ry.
Co Ill
Burrows v. G.T.R. Co. . . 502,
533, 559, 567
Burt v. Dominion Iron & Steel
Co 480
" v. Sydney 218
Burtch v. C.P.R. Co 181
Burton v. London Street Ry.
Co 156
" v. Montreal Tramwavs Co. 711
Bush v. C.P.R. Co 369
" v. Grand Trunk and Camp-
bellford, Lake Ontario
& Western Ry. Cos.
(Bush Road Crossing
Case) 468
Bush Road Crossing Case .... 468
Buskey v. C.P.R. Co 513
Byron Telephone Co. v. Bell
Telephone Co 729
Cad-Can.] Column.
Cadieux v. Montreal Street Rv.
Co 723
Cairns v. C.N.R. Co 419
Caldwell v. C.P.R. Co 460
Calgary v. C.N.R. Co 454
Calgary & Edmonton Ry. Co.
v. MacKinnon . . . 307, 308
" v. The King 613, 737
" v. Saskatchewan Land &
Homestead Co 367
Calgary Interswitching Case . . 490
Callan v. C.N.R. Co. 44
Campbell v. C.N.R. Co. .. 192, 460
" v. C.P.R. Co 110, 419
" v. Nova Scotia Steel &
Coal Co. 187
Canipbcllford. Lake Ontario &
Western R. Co. v.
Camden 454
" v. Canadian Northern On-
tario Ry. Co 232, 610
Campbellford, Lake Ontario &
Western Ry. Co., Re 359
Canada Atlantic Ry. Co. v.
Cambridge, Re . . 623,
627, 630
" v. Henderson 455
" v. Hurdman 269, 271
" v. Moxley 412
" v. Ottawa . . 341, 451, 617, 623
Canada Central Ry. Co. v.
Brown, Re 624
" v. Murray 157
" v. Regina 628
Canada Cheese Box Co. v. Can-
adian Freight Assn. . . 754
Canada & Gulf Terminal Ry.
Co. v. Fleet 490
Canada Southern Ry. Co. v.
Clouse 370
" v. Erwin 370
" v. Jackson 230
" v. Norvell 7, 299
Canada Southern Ry. Co. v.
Phelps 412
Canned Goods Tolls Case 810
Canadian Car Demurrage
Rules Case 220
Canadian China Clay Co. v.
G.T., C.P. and C.N.R.
Cos 779, 809
Canadian Condensing Co. v. C.
P.R. Co 835
Canadian and Dominion Ex-
press Cos. v. Commer-
cial Acetylene Co. . . . 585
Canadian Fraternal Assn. v.
Canadian Passenger
Assn 823
Canadian Freight Assn. v. Cad-
well Sand & Gravel
Co 772
CASES DIGESTED. is
Cam-Can.] Column. Can-Can.] Column.
Canadian Freight Assn. and In- r^K Xorthen Omaha Ry.
dnstrial Corporations. Co. T. Nand 310
Canadian Freight ASM. T. MOB- Canadian Northern Ry. Co." V. '
treal Board of Trade 808 IndfiMm ....... 246. 501
Canadian Freight Arau. T. Win- ~ T. Billings . . 23. 2! ". 331. 43
nipeg Board of Trade Canadian Northern Ry. la. and
and Canadian Mann- Blaekwood. Re 359
facturers" Assn. 130 Canadian Northern Ry. Co. T.
Canadian Gov-mment Railways Bmckwoods et aL 55 59
T. Mulgrw KCesales Canadian Northern Ry. Co. and
and Ann"* Cove Cross- Board of * Railway
Canadian Handle Mfg. Co. T. ing Case 3*5. 506
Michigan Central Ry. Canadian Northern Ry. Co. T.
Co. 816 C.PJL Co, ..". 67
Canadian Lumbermen's Asa. T. " T. CJML Co. (Kaiser
G.T.C.P. and Can. Crossing Casek MB
Xorthen Ry. Co*. . . 762 T. Diplork 123
Canadian Lumbermen's Assn. - T. G.TJL and C.P.R. Cos.
T. G.T. and CPJL f Bureau of
Cos, (Export Tolls on Case*
Lumber 8O5 * T. G.TJL and C.PJL Cos.
Canadian Lumbermen's Assn. (Mnskoka Rates Case I 833
and Montreal Board off T. G.TJL Co. 647
Trade T. G.TJL Co... 909 T. G.TJL Co. (North Bay
Manufacturers \vm.. Casei *. Ml
Green 367
Ketcheson 23
Nault
School District
35. 36
367
. 304
T. Canadian Freight
Asea. 129. 733
Canadian Manufacturers Assn.
T. Canadian Freight
Asen. (Interswitching
Rates Case. 812
Canadian Northern Express Co.
T. Rosthen 41 " T. Robinson .. 57. 3S.
Canadian Northern Ontario Ry. 365, 500
Co. T. CJML Co. 491 * T. Taylor 537
T. G.T. and C.P JL Cos. - T. Tonehette & Farrier . . 363
(Moafcoka, Rates Case* 821 * T. Winnipeg 43
r. Holditrh 150,215 Canadian Northen Street
T. MeAnuhhr 333 Crossings 593
T. North Bar 344 Canadian Northen Telegraph
T. Smith 16 Co. r. Rosthern 41
Canadian Northen Pacific Ry. Canadian Northen Western
Co. T. Armstrong. ... 43 Ry. Co. r. C.PJL Co-
Canadian Northen Pacific Ry. 346. 347. 493
Co. and Byng HaD. Re 330 " r. Moore. 23. 27. 311. 312. 333
Xorthen Pacific Ry. Canadian Oil Co. T. G.T. and
Co. r. Domnuon C.PJL Cos. 797
Glazed Cement Pipe ~ T. Grand Trunk Can. Pae.
Co. 12. 23. 309 and Can. Northen Ry.
Canadian Northen Pacific RT. Cos. 7&<
Co. and Finch. Bn .... 313 Cdi Pacific Ry. and Ca-
Canadian Northen Pacific Ry. nadian Northern Ry.
Co. r. Kelowna ". 42 Cos. T. Kamnistiquia
T. Xew Westminster . . 41. 653 Power Co. *52
T. Tenon 42. 43 * T. Regina Board of Trade
Canada Xorthen Quebec Ry. (Regina Toll Casex
Co. v. Argentenil Lam- ** T. Regina Board of Trade
ber Co. 163 (Begna Toll Case). .. 7*
" T. Desmanis 23 "' r. Allan
" T. Johnston 208 " T. Ball
v. Montreal 454 * and Batter. Re 301
CASES DIGESTED.
Can-Can.] Column.
Canadian Pacific Ry. and Cana-
dian Ry. Cos. v. Blain
117, 118
" v. Boisseau 263
" v. Brown 120
" v. Brown Milling & Ele-
vator Co 321
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. and
Byrne, Re 351
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. v. Cal-
gary 40, 475
" v. Canadian Bank of Com-
merce 98
" v. C.N.R. Co 486
" v. C.N.R. Co. (Falsework
Case) 70
" v. Canadian Oil Cos 778
" v. Carrnthers 396
" v. Clmlifoux 108
" v. Chatham 228
" v. Cheeseman 544
" v. Cobban Mfg. Co 8
" v. Coley 532, 540
" v. Coquittan Landowners. 323
" v. Dionne 532
" v. Eggleston 399
" v. Fleming 10, 176
" v. Forest City Paving &
Construction Co 106
" v. Frechette 539
" v. Gordon 321
" v. G.T.P.R. Co. (Subsidy
Land Case) 614
" v. G.T.R. Co 375, 583
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. and
G.T.R. Co., Re (Len-
noxville Crossing
Case) 608
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. v.
G.T.R. Co. (London In-
terswitching Case) . . 790
" v. G.T.R. Co. (Myrtle
Bridge Case) 70
" v. Guthrie 372
" v. Hansen 11
" v. Ilassen 562
" v. Hay 116
" v. Hinrich 193, 533
" v. Jackson 202
" v. James Bay Ry. Co. . . 54
" v. Kerr ' 16, 423
" v. The King . . 10, 65, 153, 612
" v. Lachance 206
" v. Lawson 70
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. and
Macleod Public School
District, Re 37, 40
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. v.
Major " 163
" v. McKeand 259
" v. Montreal Corn Ex-
change Assn 817
Can-Can.] Column.
" v. Montreal and Montreal
Tramways Co. (Notre
Dame Street Bridge
Case) 471
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. v.
Murphy 228, 583
" v. Nelson & Fort Sheppard
Ry. Co 128
" v. North Dumfries . . 339, 452
" v. Notre Dame de Bonse-
cours 143, 151
" v. Oakville and G.T.R. Co.
843, 844
" v. Oligny 363
" v. Ontario Department of
Public Works 653
" v. Parent . . 142, 522, 523, 544
" v. Quebec 31
" v. Quinn 204
" v. Robinson 205, 235, 554
" v. Roy 201, 416
" v. Ste. There"se 19, 361
" v. Saskatoon and Moose
Jaw Boards of Trade 491
" v. Silzer 739
" v. Smith 110, 324
" and Spanish River Pulp &
Paper Mills v. Algoma
Eastern Ry. Co 818
" v. Toronto 17, 465
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. and
Toronto, Re 36
" v. Toronto and G.T.R. Co.
(Toronto Viaduct
Case) 18, 67, 589
" v. Vancouver Ice & Cold
Storage Co 62
" v. Vancouver Westminster
& Yukon Ry. Co. 568, 604
" v. Verdun 35
" v. Walker 536
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. and
Walkerton. Re 200
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. v.
Waller 369
" v. Watts 107
" v. Western Union Tel. Co. 727
" v. Winnipeg 32, 619
" v. Winnipeg Elec. Ry. Co. 610
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. and
York, Re 579
Canadian Piano & Organ Manu-
facturers' Assn. v. Ca-
nadian Freight Assn. 129
Canadian Press v. Great North-
western, etc., Tele-
graph Cos 827
Canadian Portland Cement Co.
v. Grand Trunk & Bay
of Quinte Ry. Cos. . . 761
Canadian Railway Accident Ins.
Co. v. McNevin .... 11
CASES DIGESTED.
Caa-Cha.] Column.
Bobber Manniac-
tnres T. Canadian
Freight Assn. 755
T. The King 444
Canyon City Lumber COL T. C.
P JL Co. 62
Car Demurrage Rules (Cana-
dian Car Demurrage
Rules Ca=e> Re 221
Cardston Board of Trade T. Al-
berta Rv. & Irriga-
tion Co. 823
Carew v. G.TJL Co. 373
Carleton v. Ottawa 466, 585
" T. Rcgina 664. 696
Carlisle T. G.TJL Co. 45
Carr T. CPJL Co. . . .204, 349,
362, 501, 528
Carrier T. S1L Henri 527
Carrnthers T. C J* JL Co 396
* T. Toronto & York Radial
Ry. Co 532
Carry r. Toronto Belt Line Rv.
Co. .".227
Carson T. Weston 71
Cartage Tolls, Re 751, 818
Carter T. Montreal 4 Sorel By.
Co 636
Cartier Stop-over Case 814
Cany v. British Columbia Elec.
Ry. Co 204
Cater v. G'.TJL Co. 237
Cavanagh and Atlantic Ry. Co.,
Re " 319
Cedar Dale Crossing Case 463
Cedar Lumber Products Case 741
Central Ry. Co. Agreements. Re 601
Central Ontario Ry. Co. T.
Blackstoek '. 636
Central Ontario Ry. Co. T.
Trusts is. Guarantee
Co. 636
Central Saskatchewan Boards
of Trade T. G.T.PJL
Co 586, 839
Centra] Vermont Ry. Co. T.
Bain 535
" T. Franchere 198
" T. St. Johns 28
Cesales and Anld's Cove Cross-
ing Case 472
Chambers and C.PJL Co., Re 300
Chambers v. C.PJL Co. 595
dtmmiiri of Commerce Federa-
tion v. South Eastern
Ry. Co 593
Champagne T. G.TJL Co. 188, 189
Chan Dy Chea v. Alberta Ry. A
Irrigation Co. 44
Charlton T. The King 439
Column.
Chaleauguay & Northern Ry.
Co. T. Laurier '.. 305
" T. Trenholme 317
Chatham v. C.PJL Co. 784
" T. G.X.W. Telegraph and
Bell Telephone Cos... 856
Chatham. YVallaceburg & Lake
Erie Ry. Co. v. CJ* JL
Co. 45S
Chaudiere Machine & Foundry
Co. T. Canada Atlantic
Ry. Co. 231
Cheeseman v. C J JL Co. 544
Chew and C J JL COL, Re 482
Chisholm v. Hilifax Tram Co. 686
Christie v. London Elec. Co.
261, 28O
City Transfer Co. v. C.X JL Co. 650
Clair v. Temiscouata Ry. Co. 347
Clare v. C.XJL Co. 388
Clarey v. Ottawa Electric Ry.
Co. 706
Clark v. CJJL Co. 260. 272, 592
" v. Winnipeg and Winnipeg
Elee. Ry. Co. 548
Clarke v. C.XJL Co. 478
* v. Holliday 101
- v. London" Street Ry. Co.. . 202
Clarke and Toronto Grey A;
Bruce Ry. Co.. Re ... 322
Clarkson v. Campbellford. Lake
Ontario & Western Ry.
Co. ." . 25
Clayton v. C.X JL Co. 403
Clement v. Wentworth 629
Cleveland T. G.TJL Co. 234
Clisdell v. Kingston & Pem-
broke Ry. Co. 105. 834
Clover Bar Coal Co. v. Humber-
stone, G.TJJL etc^.
Cos. 59. 590
Coal Transportation Facilities.
Re 99, 133, 134
Cobalt v. Temiskaming Tele-
phone Co 165
Cockerline and Guelph & Code-
rich Ry. Co., Re.. 318.
374, 583
Coen v. Xew Westminster
Southern Ry. Co. .. 391
Cole v. C.X JL Co. 842
Coleman v. Toronto & Niagara
Power Co. 856
Collier v. Michigan Central Ry.
Co 846
Collin v. G.T.R. Co 536
Collins T. Can. Northern Que-
bec Ry. Co 9
Columbia Bitulithic v. British
Columbia Elec. Ry. Co.
" 707, 708
Xll
CASES DIGESTED.
Col-Cro.] Column.
Columbia & Western Ry. Co.
and the Railway Acts,
Re 144
Como v. Can. Northern Alberta
Ry. Co. and Can.
Northern Ry. Co. ... 349
Conductor A. B., Re 168
Congreave v. C.P.R. Co 650
Con ley v. C.P.R. Co 85
Connolly v. Baie des Chaleurs
R. Co 552
Conrad Mines v. White Pass &
Yukon Ry. Co 764
Consolidated Elec. Co. v. At-
lantic Trust Co 7
" v. Pratt 7
Consumer's Cordage Co. v.
Grand Trunk and Can.
Pac. Ry. Co 771
Continental Oil Co. v. C.I'.U.
Co. 290
Continental, Prairie & Winni-
peg Oil Cos. v. C.P.,
etc., Ry. Cos 590, 798
Comvay v. Canadian Transfer
Co 523
Cook v. Canadian Colleries . . 536
" v. G.T.R. Co 538
" v. North Vancouver 338
Coombs v. The Queen 734
Cooper v. London Street Ry. Co. 608
Cooperage Stock Rates Case 804
Copp Foundry Industrial Spur
Case, Fort William v.
Copp 609
Corby v. G.T.R. Co 91
Cormier v. Dominion Atlantic
Ry. Co Ill
Cornwallis v. C.P.R. Co 29
Cornwall v. Ottawa & New
York Ry. Co 40, 41
Cortese v. C.P.R'. Co 392
Cote v. G.T.R. Co 82
Cottrell v. C.P.R. Co 815
Coutlee v. G.T.R. Co 281
Courtney v. Ksquiinalt & Nan-
aimo Hy. Co 468
Cousins v. C.N.R. Co 368
" v. Moore 234
Cowichan Ratepayers Assn. v.
C.P.R. Co 809
Cox & Co. v. C.P.R. Co 768
Cox v. Nova Scotia Telephone
Co 853
Crawford v. Great Western Rv.
Co 84
Crawford v. Tilden 152, 529
Critchley v. C.N.R. Co 175
Crompton v. British Columbia
Elec. Ry. Co 505
Crossby v. Yarmouth Street Ry.
Co '.. 687
Cro-Dem.] Column.
Crows Nest Pass Coal Co. v.
C.P.R 759
Crushed Stone, etc. v. G.T.R.
Co 789
Culver v. Lester 102
Cumberland Board of Trade v.
Esquimalt & Nanaimo
Ry. Co 491
Cuneo Fruit & Importing Co. v.
G.T.R. Co 646
Cunningham v. Michigan Cen-
tral Ry. Co 270, 271
Currie v. C.P.R. Co 835
" v. Saint John Ry. Co. . . . 569
Curry v. Sandwich, Windsor &
Amherstburg Ry. Co.
114, 705
Cut Glassware Importers v. Ca-
nadian Freight Assn. 748
Cut Glass Classification Case,
Re 755
Cutknife Stations, Re 645
Dagenais v. C.N.R. Co. ..311,
366, 367, 493, 503
Daigle v. Temiscouata Ry. Co. 402
Dallontania v. McCormick, 248, 250
Daniel v. C.P.R. Co 387
Danyleski v. C.P.R. Co 504
Dariiley v. C.P.R. Co 234
Dart v. Toronto Ry. Co. . . 15, 537
Davidson v. G.T.R*. Co 395
Davie v. Nova Scotia Tram-