is a digital copy of a book that was preserved for generations on library shelves before it was carefully scanned by Google as part of a project
to make the world's books discoverable online.
It has survived long enough for the copyright to expire and the book to enter the public domain. A public domain book is one that was never subject
to copyright or whose legal copyright term has expired. Whether a book is in the public domain may vary country to country. Public domain books
are our gateways to the past, representing a wealth of history, culture and knowledge that's often difficult to discover.
Marks, notations and other marginalia present in the original volume will appear in this file - a reminder of this book's long journey from the
publisher to a library and finally to you.
Usage guidelines
Google is proud to partner with libraries to digitize public domain materials and make them widely accessible. Public domain books belong to the
public and we are merely their custodians. Nevertheless, this work is expensive, so in order to keep providing this resource, we have taken steps to
prevent abuse by commercial parties, including placing technical restrictions on automated querying.
We also ask that you:
+ Make non-commercial use of the files We designed Google Book Search for use by individuals, and we request that you use these files for
personal, non-commercial purposes.
+ Refrain from automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort to Google's system: If you are conducting research on machine
translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the
use of public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help.
+ Maintain attribution The Google "watermark" you see on each file is essential for informing people about this project and helping them find
additional materials through Google Book Search. Please do not remove it.
+ Keep it legal Whatever your use, remember that you are responsible for ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just
because we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States, that the work is also in the public domain for users in other
countries. Whether a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and we can't offer guidance on whether any specific use of
any specific book is allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Google Book Search means it can be used in any manner
anywhere in the world. Copyright infringement liability can be quite severe.
About Google Book Search
Google's mission is to organize the world's information and to make it universally accessible and useful. Google Book Search helps readers
discover the world's books while helping authors and publishers reach new audiences. You can search through the full text of this book on the web
at http : //books . google . com/|
Digitized by
Google
Digitized by VjOOQIC
Digitized by VjOOQIC
Digitized by VjOOQIC
11-
OFFICIAL EDITION ^ ^
REPORTS OF CASES
HEARD Ali^D DETBRMINBD IN THE
APPELLATE DIVISION*
OF THE
SUPREME COURT
OF THE
STATE OF NEW YORK
MAIiOUS T. HUN, Rbjpobtbjr.
Volume XXXIV.
1898.
BANKS & BROTHERS.
Nrw York. Albany, N. Y.
Digitized byCjOOQlC
Entered according to act of Congress, in the year one thousand eight hundred and ninety-eight.
By banks & BROTHERS,
in the office of the Librarian of Congress, at Washington.
/i^, ^.>/ /W
JAVKS B. LYON,
PRINTER, ELBCTROTYPER AND BINDER.
LYON BLOCK, ALBANY, N. Y.
Digitized by VjOOQIC
Justijcjes
OF
The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court.
I ^
• *
First Department,
Hov. GHAS. H. VAN BRUNT, P. J.
" GEORGE C. BARRETT.
" WILLIAM RUMSEY.
" EDWARD PATTERSON.
' MORGAN J. O'BRIEN.
" GEORGE L. INGRAHAM.
" CHESTER B. MoLAUGHLIN.
Second Department*
HOF. WILLIAM W. GOODRICH, P. J
" EDGAR M. GULLEN.
" WILLARD BARTLETT.
" EDWARD W. HATCH.
" JOHN WOODWARD.
Third Department*
HOH. CHARLES E. PARKER, P. J.
" JUDSON S. LANDON.
" D. CADY HERRICK.
" MILTON H. MERWIN.
" JOHN R. PUTNAM.
Fourth Department,
Hov. GEORGE A. HARDIN, P. J.
" DAVID L. FOLLETT.
" WILLIAM H. ADAMS.
" MANLY C. GREEN.*
» HAMILTON WARD.f
* Died October 10, 1898. f Died December 28, 1896.
Digitized by VjOOQIC
Digitized by
Google
CA USES in which the decisions contained in IlurCs RejporU
and in the Appellate Division Reports home ieen passed upon
by the Court of Appeals.
Bates v. Salt Spbings Nat. Bakk 88 Hun, 236
Judgment reversed and new tnal ordered : 157 N. T. 822.
Boyd v. Gorman 29 App. Div. 428
Appeal dismissed : 15ZiV: F. 366.
Canda ». ToTTEHi 87 Hun, 72
Jttdgment of t/ie General I'erm reversed and that of the Special Term affii*med :
157 N. T. 281.
De Witt t. Agricultural Ins. Co 89 Hun, 229
Judgment affirmed: 157 N. T. 858.
Eames Vacuum Brake Co. y. Prosseb 88 Hun, 848
Judgment affli-med : 157 N. T. 289.
Hannioan v. Lehigh & Hudson River R. Co 91 Hun, 300
Judgment reversed and new trial granted : 157 N. T. 244.
Hirshfeld V, Bopp 27 App. Div. 180
Order of the AppeUate Division reversed and judgment entered on the decision of the
trial court affirmed: 157 iV". T. 166.
Lowenthal v. Lowenthal 92 Hun, 885
Judgment and orders affirmed : 157 N. T. 286.
Matter op Beck 31 App. Div. 361
Orders reversed and pi'oceedings remitted to the Special Term for furtlier disposition :
157 N. T. 151.
Matter of Henderson 33 App. Div. 545
Order affirmed: 157 xV. T. 423.
Matter op the Mayor 28 App. Div. 143
Order affirmed: 157 iV'. T. 409.
Moot v. Business Men's Investment Assn 90 Hun, 155
Judgments reversed and new trial granted : 157 N. T, 201.
Myers v. Bolton 89 Hun, 342
Judgtnent modified : 157 ^. Y. 393.
People ex rel. Armstrong Cork Co. v. Barker 31 App. Div. 263
Older of the Appellate Division modified by restoring the assessment of the relator
to its original amount as fixed by the defendants, and as so Tuodified affirmed : 157
j^. r. 159.
People ex rel. Jones v. Feitner 32 App. Div. 23
Order affirmed : 157 A". Y. 363.
People ex rel. Coler v. Lord 29 App. Div. 455
Appeal dismissed : 157 K Y. 408.
People ex rel. Sweet v. Lyman. 30 App. Div. 135
Oi'der affirmed : 157 iV". Y. 368.
Perry v. Rogers 91 Hun, 243
Judgment reversed and new trial granted : 157 N. Y. 251.
Digitized by VjOOQIC
vi CAUSES PASSED UPON BY COURT OF APPEALS.
Sanger v. Frbnch 91 Hun, 599
80 mucfi of the order of the General Term as reverses the judgment in favor of the
plaintiff and directs a new trial reversed, and the judgment entered on the report
of the rrferee affiimed: 157 N, Y. 213.
Smith v. Secor 81 App. Div. 108
Order affirmed : 157 N. Y, 402.
Tinker v. N. Y., Ontario & Western R. Co 92 Hun, 269
Judgment affirmed: 157 N. Y. 312.
Ward v. Petrib 92 Hun, 605
Judgment reversed and hew trial granted : 157 X. Y. 301.
Warren v. Union Bank op Rochester 28 App. Div. 7
Judgment reversed and that of the Special Term affirmed : 157 N. Y. 259.
The attention of the profession is ciilled to the fact that the Court of Appeals
in many cases decide an appc<\l upon other grounds than those stated in the opin-
ion of the court below.
The affirmance or reversal of the judgment of the Appellate Division does not
necessarily show that the Court of Appeals concurred in, or dissented from, the
statements contained in the opinion of the Supreme Court. (Rogers v. Decker,
131 N. Y. 490.)— [Rep.
Digitized by VjOOQIC
A TABLE
NAMES OF THE CASES REPORTED
IN THIS VOLUMK
-^« PAGE.
Abbott, Tate v 627
Ackennan, Gilbert v 681
Adler Veneer Seat Co., Woodcock
V 626
Ahrens & Ott Mfg. Co., Droege v.. 681
Aldhous, Emil v 681
Allan, Cameron v 681
Allen, Smith v 624
Altman. Jacobs v 681
American Boiler Co. v. Fontham. . 294
American Credit Indemnity Co.,
Jaeckel v 665
American Credit Indemnity Co.,
Schattman v 892
American Distributing Co., Hof-
heimer v 628
Anglim, Fulton Grain & Milling
Co. V 164
Astrand v. Brooklyn Heights R. R.
Co. (2 cases) 624
Auld V. Manhattan Life Ins. Co. . . 491
B.
Ballard, People ez rel., v. Moss. 476, 681
Balz V. Underbill 681
Bartlett, Henderson v 627
Bates V. Virolet 629
Battersby v. Collier 347
Bauer, Toplitz v 526
Beakes, Nugent v 123
Beck, People ex rel., v. Coler 167
Bell V. Moen's Asphaltic Cement
Co 628, 624
Benedict, Creighton v 627
Birch V. Kavanaugh Knitting Co. . 614
PAOB.
Blake v. Reilly 628
Blaut V. Fletcher 888
Bliss, Bush V 624
Bloomingdale, Montgomery v 875
Board of Education, Matter of . . . . 680
Board of Street Opening, Matter of. 600
Bradley v. Second Avenue R. R.
Co 284
Brandreth, Gerlach v 197
Breen v. Lennon 680
Broadway Ferry & Met. Ave. R. R.
Co., Kalfur v 267
Brooklyn, City of, Covert v 627
Brooklyn, City of. Worth v 228
Brooklyn Elevated R. R. Co., Mat-
ter of, V. Voss 626
Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., As-
trand V. (2 cases) 624
Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Cap-
parellav 627
Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Devine
V 248
Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., John-
son V 271
Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Mey-
errose v 627
Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., Re-
hagev 628
Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co.,
Schramm v 626
Brown, Lyon v 828, 680
Brown v. Wadsworth 628
Bullenkamp v. Bullenkamp 198
Bums V. Burns 626
Bush V. Bliss 624
Digitized by
Google
Vlll
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED.
Bush, Douglass v 226
Byrnes, Rosenfield v 624
c.
Calahan v. Mayor 344
Camerick, Matter of 81
Cameron v. Allan 681
Cannon, People ex rd. Harvey v. . 627
Cannon, People ex rel., v. Van
Wyck 636
Capparella v. Brooklyn Heights R.
R. Co 627
Carll y. Long Island City (and 18
other cases) 627
Gary, O'Beirne v. . 828
Caahmaker v. Nassau Electric R.
R. Co 626
Chanler v. New York Elevated R.
R. Co 306
Chapman, Hubbard v 252
Chapman. Wheelock v 464
Chatterton v. Chatterton 245
Chew, Zimmer v 504
City of Brooklyn, Covert v 627
City of Brooklyn, Worth v 228
City of Mount Vernon, Johnson v. 87
aty of New York, Koelesch v. . . . 98 |
City of New York, Lorey v 626
City of New York, McKenna v 152
City of New York, Stern v 627
Clark, Sullivan v 630
Coler, People ex rel. Beck v 167
Collier. Battersby v 347
Colwell V. Tietig 624
Coney Island & Brooklyn R. R. Co.,
Linehan v 627
Congregational Unitarian Soc., Mat
terof 387
Conklin, Place v 191
Connolly v. New York Central &
H. R. R. R. Co 680
Continental Filter Co., Williamson
V 630
Cook, Matter of 627
Cook V. Metropolitan Elevated R.
Co 631
Cook V. White 623, 627
Comwell, Daly v 27
Covert V. City of Brooklyn 627
Cowles Engineering Co., Vande-
grift V 631
Crabtree v. Otterson 628
Cram, People ex rel. Cunlifle v. . . . 818
Crandall Co., Montignani v 228
Crawford, Faile v 278
Crawford v. Winston 457
Creed, Ellison v 15
Creighton v. Benedict 627
Cropsey v. Hanneman 625
Cross, Wilson v 625
Cunliffe, People ex rel., v. Cram. . . 818
D.
Dalton, People ex rel. Fleming v. . 627
Dalton, People ex rel. Tate â–¼ 6
Dalton, People ex rel. Warschauer
V 802
Daly V. Comwell 27
Daniels, People ex rel., v. Kearny. 680
Dawson, Lawrence v 211
Dayton, Elting v 680
Dean v. Third Avenue R. R. Co. . . 220
D* Arcy v. Long Island R. R. Co. . . 275
De Berard v. Prial 502
De Klyn v. Simpson 486
Delawai'e & Hudson Canal Co.,
Pagev 618
Devine v. Brooklyn Heights R. R.
Co 248
Devlin v. Hinman 107
Dickinson v. Earle 559
Dietz V. Leber 626
Dietz V. Yetter 458
Dilthey , Donlon v 627
Dolan V. Rothschild. 631
Donlon v. Dilthey 627
Dorney v. O'Neill 497
Douglass V. Bush 226
Drake v. New York Iron Mine . . . 623
Droege v. Ahrens & Ott Mfg. Co. . 631
Duryea, Herbert v 478
Dwyer v. Mayor 450
Dykman v. Keeney 45
E.
Earle, Dickinson v 559
East One Hundred and Seventy-
sixth St., Matter of 631
Digitized by
Google
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED.
12
PAOB.
Eastern Brewing Co., Hey man v. . 624
Eckerson, People ex rel., v. Zundel. 626
Ehrmann v. Nassau Electric R. R.
Co 626
Ellison V. Creed 15
Elting V. Dayton 630
EI well. People ex rel., v. Manhattan
Chess Club 681
Emil V. Aldhous 681
Emslie v. Livingston 188
Erie R. R. Co., Miller v 217
Everard's Breweries, Lacs v 626
Ewen, Reuss v 484
Exempt Firemen Assn. v. Trustees. 188
F.
Faile v. Crawford 278
Fargo, Kutner v 817
Ferguson, Stewart v 615
Ferguson & Co., Smith v 624
Ferrigan, Matter of 681
Ferris v. Ferris 144
Fichten, Nadel v 188
Field V. Port Chester St. R. Co. . . . 627
First National Bank, Sinnott v 161
Fitzpatrick v. Moses 242
Fleming, People ex rel., v. Dalton. 627
Fletcher, Blaut v 888
Fluhr V. Manhattan R. Co 624
Fontham, American Boiler Co. v. . 2d4
Friedman, Mayer v 627
Friedman, Sternbach v 684
Frost, Matter of 681
Fulton Grain & Milling Co. v. An-
glim 164
G.
Gans, Trowbridge v 630
Gardam v. Healy 624
Gas Engine & Power Co., Hand v. 854
Gates V. Gates 608
Geer, Niland v 624
Gkrlach v. Brandreth 1»7
Ghee v. Northern Union Gas Co. . . 661
Gilbert v. Ackerman 631
Goldsmith v. Metropolitan St. R.
Co 631
Ch)ugh V. Jewett 624
Green, People ex rel., v. Van Wyck. 573
App. Div.— Vol. XXX
^' PAO«.
Haber, Matter of 680
Hagedom v. Lang 117
Haight, Leach v 622
Hall V. Ochs 103
Hand v. Gas Engine & Power Co. . 364
Hanneman, Cropsey v 625
Harvey v. Nicoll & Roy Co 631
Harvey, People ex rel., v. Cannon. 627
Hassen v. Nassau Electric R. R.
Co 71
Hauk V, New York, N. H. & H.
R.R. Co 484
Hauscheld v. Hauscheld 681
Hawkins v. Pelham Electric Light
&PowerCo 627.
Healy, Gardam v 624
Heermance, Wilcock v 623
Heiberger v. Johnson 66
Heiberger v. Long Island City (and
3 other cases) 627
Henderson v. Bartlett 627
Henderson, Matter of 624
Henry v. Salisbury 631
Herbert v. Duryea 478
Heyman v. Eastern Brewing Co, . . 624
Higgins V. MetropoUtan St. R. Co. 631
Hinman, Devlin v 107
Hirsch, Tisch v 628
Hoag V. Wright 260
Hoffman v. New York Elevated R.
R. Go 631
Hofheimer v. American Distribut-
ing Co 628
Howard v. Port Chester St. R. Co. . 627
Hubbard v. Chapman 262
Hyatt, Woodburn v 246
I.
Irving Nat. Bank v. WilBon Bros.
Co 481
J.
Jackson v. Mayor 630
Jacobs V. Altman 631
Jaeckel v. American Credit Indem-
nity Co 565
Jaeger, Mutual Benefit Loan Co. v.. 90
James, People ex rel. , v. Mount Zion
Lodge No. 1670 625
V. ii
Digitized by
Google
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED.
PAOB.
Jewett, Gough v 628
Johnson v. Brooklyn Heights R.
R. Co 271
Johnson v. City of Mount Vernon.. 87
Johnson, Heiberger v 66
Joyce, Matter of 624
K.
Kalfur V. Broadway Ferry & Met,
Ave.R. R. Co 267
Kane, People ex rel., v. Roosevelt.. 630
Katte V. Taylor 631
Eavanaugh Knitting Co., Birch v. . 614
Eear, Sweeny v 627
iKeams, Partridge v 623
Kearny, People ex rel. Daniels v. . . 630
Keegan v. Third Avenue R. R. Co.. 297
Keenan, Townshend v. (6 cases) . . . 629
Keeney, Dykman v 45
Keister v. Rankin 288
Kelly V. Werner 68
Kemp V. New York Produce Ex-
change 175
Kempner v. Potts 681
Kennedy v. Mayor 811
Kennedy v. Third Avenue R. R.
Co 631
Kirby v. Kirby 25
Koehne v. New York & Queens
County R. Co 624
Koelesch v. City of New York ... 98
Kohlmann v. Selvage 380
Kutner v. Fargo 317
L.
Lacs V. Everard's Breweries 626
Laird v. Littlefield 42
Lake v. Metropolitan St. R. Co 681
Lancashire Insurance Co., Parker v. 631
Lang, Hagedorn v 117
Lawrence v. Dawson 211
Lazarus, Matter of 624
Leach v. Haight 522
Learned v. Mayor 630
Leber, Dietz v 626
Leffingwell, Littlejohn v. 185
Lennon, Breen v 630
Leubischer, People ex rel. MacDon-
aldv 577
PAOB.
Leubischer, People ex rel. Strauss
V 630
Lewis, Victor v 631
Linehan v. Coney Island & Brooklyn
R.R. Co 627
Littlefield, Laird V 48
Littlejohn v. Leffingwell. . 185
Livingston, Emslie v 188
Long Island City, Carll v. (and 13
other cases) 627
Long Island City, Heiberger v. (and
8 other cases) 627
Long Island Railroad Co., D'Arcy
V 275
Loretz v. Metropolitan St. R. Co. . . 1
Lorey v. City of New York 626
Lyman, Matter of 389, 681
Lynch, Tracey v 627
Lyon V. Brown 323, 680
M.
MacDonald, People ex rel., v. Leu-
bischer 577
Mack, Saugerties Bank v 494
Manhattan Chess Club, People ex
rel. Elwell v 631
Manhattan Life Ins. Co., Auld v. . . 491
Manhattan R. Co., Fluhr v 624
Manheim v. Seitz 624
Martin v. Nassau Electric R. R.
Co 627
Matter of Board of Education 630
Matter of Board of Street Opening. 500
Matter of Brooklyn Elevated R. R.
Co. V. Voss 626
Matter of Camerick 31
Matter of Congregational Unitarian
Soc 887
Matter of Cook • . 627
Matter of East One Hundred and
Seventy-sixth St 631
Matter of Ferrigan 631
Matter of Frost 681
Matter of Haber 680
Matter of Henderson 624
Matter of Joyce 624
Matter of Lazarus 624
Matter of Lyman 389, 631
Matter of the Mayor 468
Digitized by
Google
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED.
zi
Matter of the Mayor (Twelfth Ward
Park) 630
Matter of McDonald 512
Matter of Morris 627
Matter of MuUer 631
Matter of Noble 55
Matter of Norton 79
Matter of Portchester R. Co 627
Matter of Porter 147
Matter of Handel 631
Matter of Raymond 624
Matter of Reynolds. 681
Matter of Salomon 624
Matter of School Board 49
Matter of Scott 624, 627
Matter of Trapnell 626
Matter of Twelfth Ward Park (Lot
No. 160) 631
Matter of Twelfth Ward Park (Re
Barilati) 631
Matter of Twelfth Ward Park (Re
Ramangton) 631
Matter of Twelfth Ward Park (Re
Scangarella) 681
Matter of Weld 471
Matter of Wescott 239
Matter of West 624
Matter of Westchester Trust Ck) . 628, 624
Matter of York 627
Mayer v. Friedman 627
Mayor, Calahan v 344
Mayor, Dwyer V 450
Mayor, Jackson v 630
Mayor, Kennedy v 311
Mayor, Learned v 630
Mayor, Matter of the 468
Mayor, Matter of the (Twelfth Ward
Park) 630
Mayor, Stemmler v 408
Mayor, Tyrrell V 334
McCartney, People ex rel. Schu-
mann v 19
McCormack v. Nassau Electric R.
R. Co 624
McDonald, Matter of 512
McKenna v. City of New York 152
McKim V. New York Elevated R.
R. Co 631
Medical Society, People ex rel., v.
Neff 88;
PAGK.
Megowan, Wendt v 680
Merges v. Ringler 415
Mershon, People ex rel., v. Shaw. . 61
Meserole V. Sinn 83
Metropolitan Elevated R. Co., Cook
V 681
Metropolitan Street R. Co., Gold-
smith v 681
Metropolitan Street R. Co., Hig-
gins V 631
Metropolitan Street R. Co., Lake
V 631
Metropolitan Street R. Co., Loretz
V 1
Metropolitan Street R. Co., Weiss
V 681
Meyerrose v. Brooklyn Heights R.
R. Co 627
Miller v. Erie R. R. Co. . . .' 217
Miller, Seibert v 602
Millie Iron Mining Co. v. Thal-
mann 281
Moen's Asphaltic Cement Co., Bell
V 628, 624
Montgomery v. Bloomingdale 875
Montignani v. Crandall Co. . . : 228
Morris, Matter of 627
Morrison, People ex rel., v. Roose-
velt 630
Moses, Fitzpatrick v 242
Moss, People ex rel. Ballard v. .475, 631
Mount Vernon, City of, Johnson v. 37
Mount Zion Lodge No. 1670, Peo-
pie ex rel. James v 625
Muller, Matter of 681
Murray v. Village of Port Jervis. . 628
Mutual Benefit Loan Co. v. Jaeger. 90
N.
Naab v. Stewart 624
Nadel v. Fichten 188
Nassau Bank v. National Bank 628
Nassau Electric R. R. Co., Cash-
maker v 626
Nassau Electric R. R. Co., Ehrmann
V 626
Nassau Electric R. R. Co., Hassen
V 71
Nassau Electric R. R Co., Martin
V 627
Digitized by
Google
zu
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED.
PAOE.
Nassau Electric R. R. Co., McCor-
mack V 624
Nassau Electric R. R. Co., O'Flah-
erty V 74
Nassau Electric R. R. Co., Young
V 126
National Bank, Nassau Bank v 623
National Lead Co., Rcissman v 631
National Wall Paper Co. v. Sire. . . 681
Neff, People ex rel. Medical Society
V 88
New Haven Steamboat Co., Scha-
yer V 626
New York Bay Extension R. R.
Co., Ray V 8
New York Central & H. R. R. R.
Co., Connolly v 680
New York Central & H. R. R. R.
Co., Penny v 10
New York, City of, Koelesch v. . . . 98
Now York, City of, Lorey v 626
New York, City of, McKenna v. . . 152
New York, City of, Stern v 627
New York Elevated R. R. Co.,
Chanler v: 305
New York Elevated R, R. Co.,
Hoffman v 681
New York Elevated R. R. Co.,
McKim V 681
New York Iron Mine, Drake v 628
New York, Lake Erie & Western
R. R. Co., Timpson v 628, 625
New York, N. H. & H. R. R. Co.,
Hauk V 434
New York Produce Exchange,
Kemp V 175
New York & Queens County R. Co.,
Koehne V 624
Nicoll & Roy Co., Harvey v 631
Niland v. Geer 624
Noble, Matter of 65
Northern Union Gas Co., Ghee v. . 551
Norton, Matter of 79
Nugent V. Beakes 123
o.
O'Beirne v. Cary 828
O' Flaherty v. Nassau Electric R.
R. Co 74
PAOB.
O'Neill, Dorney v 497
Oakes v. Oakes 681
Ochs, Hall V 103
Ordway, People ex rel., v. St. Sav-
iour's Sanitarium 363
Ott, Wissel V 159
Otterson, Crabtree v 628
P.
Page V. Delaware & Hudson Canal
Co 618
Parker v. Lancashire Ins. Co 681
Partridge v. Kearns 628
Pelham Electric Light & Power
Co., Hawkins v 627
Pelham Hod Elevating Co., Rich
V 626,627
Penny v. New York Central & H.
R. R. R. Co 10
People ex rel. Harvey v. Cannon. . 627
People ex rel. Beck v. Coler 167
People ex rel. Cunliflfe v. Cram 818
People ex rel. Fleming v. Dalton. . 627
People ex rel. Tate v. Dalton 6
People ex rel. Warsohauer v. Dal-
ton...*. 803
People ex rel. Daniels v. Kearny . . 630
People ex rel. MacDonald v. Leu-
bischer 577
People ex rel. Strauss v. Leubischer. 630
People ex rel. Elwell v. Manhattan
Chess Club 681
People ex rel. Schumann v. McCart-
ney 19
People ex rel. Ballard v. Moss. 475, 631
People ex rel. James v. Mount Zion
Lodge No. 1670 625
People ex rel. Medical Society v.
Neff 88
People ex rel. Kane v. Roosevelt. . 630
People ex rel. Morrison v. Roose-
velt 630
People ex rel. Mershon v. Shaw^ 61
People ex rel. Ordway v. St. Sav-
iour's Sanitarium 368
People V. Sullivan 544
People ex rel. Cannon v. Van
Wyck 630
People ex rel. Green v. Van Wyck. 578
Digitized by
Google
TABLE OF CASES REPORTED.
xiu
PAOB.
People ex rel. Tucker v. Van Wyck. 630
People V. Willis 208
People ex rel. Eekerson v. Zundel. 626
Phenix iDsurance Co., Starbuck v. 293
Pbenix Insurance Co., Thebaud v. 630
Place V. Conklin 191
Port Chester St. U. Co., Field v. . . 627
Port Chester St. R. Co., Howard
V 627
Port Chester St. R. Co., Matter of. 627
Port Jervis. M. & N. Y. R. R. Co.,
Van Inwegen v 95
Port Jervis, Village of, Murray v. . 628
Porter, Matter of 147
Potter V. Potter 631
Potts, Kempner v 631
Prial, De Berard V 602
Puels, Woolley v 626
Q.
Quirk, Raffael V 627
R.
Raffael V. Quirk 627
Randel, Matter of 631
Rankin, Keister v 288
Rappaport v. Werner 625
Ray V. New York Bay Extension
R. R. Co 8
Raymond, Matter of 624
Rehage v. Brooklyn Heights R. R.
Co 628
Rdlly, Blakev 628
Reilly v. Sicilian Asphalt Paving
Co 631
Reissmann v. National Lead Co . . . 631
Reynolds, Matter of 631
Rich V. Pelham Hod Elevating
Co 626, 627
Ringler, Merges v 415
Riverside Bank v. Woodhaven
June. L. Co 869
Robinson v. Smith 626
Roosevelt, People ex rel. Kane v. . 630
Roosevelt, People ex rel. Morrison
V 630
Rosenbaum v. VoUmer 630
Rosenfleld v. Byrnes 624
Rothschild, Dolan v 631
PAGB.
Ruess V. Ewen 484
Ruppert, Solomons v 230
S.
Salisbury, Henry v 631
Salomon, Matter of 624
Saugerties Bank v Mack 494
Schattman v. Am. Credit Indem-
nity Co 392
Schayer v. New Haven Steamboat
Co 626
School Board, Matter of 49
Schopp, Wisner v 199
Schramm v. Brooklyn Heights R.
R. Co 626
Schroeder v. Shrady 626
Schumann, People ex rel., v. Mc-
Cartney 19
Scott, Matter of 624. 627
Second Ave. R. R. Co., Bradley v. 284
Seibert v. Miller 602
Seitz, Manheim 624
Selvage, Kohlmann v 380
Shanks v. Stumpf 623, 624
Shanley v. Shanley 172
Shaw, People ex rel. Mershon v . . . 61
Shaw, Woolsey v 405
Shrady, Schroeder v 525
Sicilian Asphalt Paving Co., Reilly
V 631
Sieg el-Cooper Co., Standard Fashion
Co. V 631
Simpson, De K!yn v 436
Sinn, Meserole v 33
Sinnott v. First National Bank ... 161
Sire, National Wall Paper Co. v. . . 631
Smith V. Allen 624
Smith V. Ferguson & Co 624