Francis H. (Francis Hermann) Bohlen.

Cases on the law of torts (Volume 1) online

. (page 2 of 124)
Font size
QR-code for this ebook

(a) Words imputing the commission of certain crimes.. 790

(b) Words imputing certain diseases 802

(c) Words injurious to the plaintiff's reputation in his

trade, business, profession or office 803

(d) Defamatory words causing actual harm, other than

the mere impairment of the plaintiff's reputation. . 820

Section 2. — Libel 826

Section 3. — Publication 833

(a) Repetition and dissemination of defamatory state-

fnents of others 839

(b) Publication of defamatory truths 846

Section 4. — Defendant's Intention to Injure the Plaintiff's Reputa-
tion SoO

Section 5. — Plaintiff's Consent to be Defamed 871

I CHAPTER III.

* Disparagement of Property.

(a) Disparagement of title ("slander of title") 873

(b) Disparagement of quality ( trade libel) 879



TABLE or CONTENTS XIU

CHAPTER IV.

Page
Harm Intentionally Caused by the Publication of Statements Not
IN Themselves Defamatory 888



BOO K III <^

JUSTIFICATIONS, EXCUSES AND DEFENSES.

PART I

Defense of Person or Property and the Assertion of Right in Respect

Thereto.

CHAPTER I.

Self-Defense.

(a) Defense of one's person from ivrongful violence 891

(b) Defense of others from wrongful violence 900

(c) Defense of one's property from -wrongful intrusion 903

(d) Intrusion upon or destruction of property required by individual

or public necessity 915

CHAPTER II.
Self-Help.

(a) Re-entry upon real property 920

(b) Recaption of personal property 927

(c) Abatement of nuisances 940

(d) Use of force necessary for the preservation of discipline 947

PART II

Acts Harmful to Others Excused Because Freedom of Action or the Act

Is Regarded as of Social Benefit.

CHAPTER I.

Conduct Excused Because of the Necessity of Preserving the Inde-
pendence of the Sovereign in Its Dealings v^^th Other Nations.. 955

CHAPTER II.

Conduct Excused When Necessary to Secure the Proper Administra-
tion OF Justice.

Section 1. — Immunity of the Judiciary 956

Section 2. — hnmunity of Witnesses 972

Section 3. — The Right to Arrest With or Without Warrant or to
yj Seize Property under Judicial Process 974

(a) Arrest ivithout zcarrant 974

(b) Arrest under ivarrant and seizure of goods under

judicial process 987

Section 4. — Right to Institute Legal Proceedings for the Punishment

I % t^ / ^f Crime or for Private Redress 990

Y *jr y\ (a) Malicious prosecution 99Q

Cvv (kr / ^^) I'tstitution of proceedings and their termination 990



./




xiv TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

(2) Nature of the proceedings 1011

(3) Want of probable cause and malice 1020

(a) Guilt of persons prosecuted and acquitted. 1035

(b) Abuse of process 1036

CHAPTER III.

Defamation Excused by the Necessity of Preserving the Right to
Speak Freely when such Freedom Is to the Public Interest or

Necessary for the Protection of the Speaker or Others

Section 1. — "Absolute Privilege" — Defeasible Immunity ..1037

(a) Immunity of judges, witnesses, counsel and parties

to actions 1037

(b) Immunity of legislators and governmental officers. .1049
Section 2. — Qualified Privilege — Defeasible Immunity 1055

(a) Communications made for the protection of the

•maker's property, interests, or reputation 1055

(b) Communications for the protection of the common

interests of the maker and the recipient 1065

(c) Communications made for the protection of others.. 1074

(1) Where a relation exists making it the maker's

duty to protect the recipient ._ 1074

(2) Where no relation exists making it peculiarly

the duty of the maker to protect the recipient's
interests ; • 1081

(a) Communicatiojis made in answer to inqui-

ries 1081

(b) Communications volunteered by the maker. 1085

(d) Communications made to aid the administration ef

justice 1099

Section 3. — The Right to Publish Reports of Legislative, Judicial and

Public Proceedings 1101

Section 4. — The Right to Comment upon Matters of Public Interest

{"Fair Comment") • 1118

Section 5. — Abuse of Conditional Immunity 1140

(a) Excessive publication 1140

(b) "Malice" 1153

CHAPTER IV.

Acts Necessary to Secure One's Economic Advancement by Acts
Necessarily or Intentionally Harmful to Others.
Section 1. — Nature of the Harm Done — Interference with Business

or Employment 1167

(a) By inducing third persons to break their contracts

with the plaintiff _. ; 1167

(b) By force, threats or other means tortious in them-

selves ; \\i6

(c) By interference with the freedom of opportunity to

contract or to obtain labor or employment {The

right to "the freedom of the market.").. . . 1179

Section 2. — The Actor's Economic Advancement as a J stification. .\IS7

(1) For the use of force, threats or other tortious meatts.l\87

(2) For inducing the breach of contracts 1192

(3) For the use of economic power as a means of com-

pulsion 1 197

(a) Conflicting interests of employer and employed A\97

(1) The right to strike 1197

(2) The right to boycott 1228

(b) Competition between trade rivals 1241

(1) The right to induce exclusive dealings by

promising or giving economic advantages. \24l

'4



/



TABLE OF CONTENTS XV

Pace
(2) The right to use one's economic power over
third persons to prevent them employing
or dealing with the plaintiff {Trade Boy-
cotts. ) 1249

(4) For the use of agreements surrendering the freedom

of the individual to the will of the majority 1274

Section 3. — The Effect of a Dominating Desire to Injure the Plaintiff . 1276

CHAPTER V.

Regulation of the Exercise of Mutually Conflicting Rights.

Section 1. — Rights Enjoyed by All Citizens {Use of Highways) .. A283

Section 2. — Right to Freedom of Choice in Use of Land 1290

Section 3. — The Right to Appropriate the Benefit of Natural Re-
sources Common to Several Landowners 1306

CHAPTER VI.

Acts Directed or Permitted by Legislative Enactment 1320

PART III

The Effect of the Plaintiff's Fault as a Bar to Recovery for Injury

Caused in Part Thereby.

CHAPTER I.

The Plaintiff's Deliberate Choice to Encounter a Known Risk

Created by the Defendant 1345

CHAPTER II.

Contributory Negligence 1359

Section 1. — Negligence Contributing to an Injury as a Bar to Liability

Arising Out of Other than Merely Negligent Conduct .1363

(a) Conduct entailing liability not dependent on proof

of negligence 1363

(b) Conduct intentionally injurious 1364

(c) Wilful, wanton and reckless misconduct 1366

(d) The Admiralty rule of divided damages 1371

(e) Comparative negligence 1372

Section 2. — Contributory A'egligoice as a Bar to Liability for the

Breach of Statutory Duty 1373

Section 3. — The Defendant's Ability to Avoid Injury to the Plain-
tiff Exposed Thereto by His Own Negligence {"Last

Clear Chance" Doctrine.) 1378

Section 4. — Contributory Negligence of Persons Other than the

Plaintiff {Imputed Negligence) 1412

CHAPTER III.
Plaintiff's Breach of Statutory Duty 1433

CHAPTER IV.
Causal Connection Between the Plaintiff's Conduct and Injury... ,1445



TABLE OF CASES



Page
Abrath v. North Western Ry. Co. ;

Bowen, L. J. in, 1024

Adams ?'. Freeman 86

Adams v. Lawson 834

Addington v. Allen 773

Ainsworth v. Lakin 607

Aldrich V. Wright 912

Alexander v. Jenkins 816
Alger V. Duluth, etc., Trac. Co.; Start,

C. J. in, 1366

Anderson v. Gorrie 957

Andre v. Johnson 934

Andrew v. Deshler 878

Anonymous, Choke, C. J. in, 916

Anonymous, L. A., 26 Edw. III. 96

Anonymous, L. A., 9 Viner's Abr. 96

Anonymous, 19 Hen. VI. 317

Anonymous, 20 Hen. VI. 316

Anonymous, Rede, C. J. in, 915

Anonymous, Y. B., 14 Edw. III. 95

Anonymous, Y. B., 9 Edw. IV. 940

Anonymous, Y. B., 11 Edw. IV. 676

Anonymous, Y. B., 11 Edw. VI. 761

Anthony v. Slaid 192

Armory i'. Delamirie 97

Ashby v. White 177

Atchison, T. & S. F. Ry. Co. z: Baker 1368

Atwood V. Chapman 668

Austin V. Barrows 784



B.



Badoit V. Andre 1319

Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. v. Cain 980
Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. v. O'Don-

ncll 175
Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. z: Sul-
phur Springs School Dist. 262
Barclay v. Abraham 1310
Barger ?•. Barringer 1293
Barrett v. Lake Ontario, etc., Co. 464
Barry v. N. Y. C. & H. R. R. Co. 419
Beach v. Hancock 18
Beatty v. Central Iowa R. R. Co. 196
Beaulieu v. Finglam 556



Benton 7'. Pratt

Berry v. Sugar Notch Borough

Bird v. Holbrook

Bird i: Jones

Birmingham Ry. Co. v. Bowers; Cole-
man, J. in.

Bishop f. Montague

Bishop t'. Weber

Blades ?'. Higgs

Blake v. Woolf

BIyth V. Birmingham Water Works Co.

Bott i: Pratt

Boulfrois V. United Trac. Co.

Bourn v. Davis

Bourne ?•. Whitman

BoutwcII f. Marr

Bower ?• Peate

Bowman z: Brown and Ilall

Box t'. Jubb

Bradley z: Heath

Bragg z: Laraway; Rowcll, J. in,

Broderick z: James

Bromage z'. Prosser; Bayley, J. in.

Brow z: Hathaway

Brown & Allen -■. Jacob's Pharmacy
Co.

Brown, Hussey & Erith z\ Howard

Brown ;■. Kendall

Bruce z: Soule

Brushaber v. Stegemann

Buch z: Amory Mfg. Co.

Buck z: Colbath

Bucknam z\ Great Northern Ry. Co.

Bunting v. Hogsett

Burns v. Erben

Burt z; Advertiser Newspaper Co

Burt z'. Smith

Burton z\ Moorhead

Busterud z: Farrington

Butterfield z\ Barber

Butterfield z'. Forrester

Byam v. Collins



Cadwcll 7'. Farrcll

Cahill z\ Cincinnati, etc., Ry. Co.



Page

689

1452

381

32

1367
135
517
927
589
197
351

1451
754

1436

1274
636
929
587

1158

37

833

1154

1055

1269

952

57

802

31

299

997

21?

248

974

1135

1020

533

753

721

1359

1083



r?

1413



XVI 1



XVlll



TABLE OF CASES.



""aledonian Rj'. Co. v
Callanan •:•. Gilman

Martin

V. K. C, F.



Mulholland



S. & M. R. R.



. Seaman
. Spottiswoode
McConnell; Faircloth,



C.



Camp
Campbell t

Co.
Campbell 5
Campbell i
Cardon v.

J. in,
Carr v. Hood
Castle V. Houston
Cavanaugh v. Boston & Maine R. R.

Co.
Cayzer v. Carron
Chambers v. Bedell

Chapleyn of Greye's Inne v

Chatham Furnace Co. v. Moffatt

Chatterton v. Secretary of State

Cheetham '■. Hampson

City & Suburban Ry. Co. v. Moores

Clark V. Downing

Clark V. Foot

Clark V. Molyneux

Clay V. Wood

Clayards v. Dethick

Clifton V. Lange

Coffin V. Coffin

Coggs V. Bernard

Cogswell V. X. Y., N. H. & H. R. R.

Co.
Cole V. Turner
Coleman v. MacLennan
Coleman v. MacLennan
Coleman v. MacLennan
Collins V. Middle Level Commissioners
Comer v. Knowles
Consolidated Co. v. Curtis
Corby v. Hill

Corporation of Bradford v. Pickles
Cote V. Murphy
Cotton V. Willmar & Sioux Falls Ry.

Co.
Covington Bridge Co. v. Steinbrock

and Patrick
Cowley V. Smyth
Coxhead v. Richards
Cruden v. Fentham
Cunningham v. International Ry Co.;

Bonner, J. in,
Cunningham v. Yeoman
Curtley v. Security Savings Society



D.



Pagh
4S-1

1283
809

329
1351
1121

1061

1118

846

1397

1371

935

891

704

1053

458

653

25

558

1160

1346

1346

1125

1049

308

1333

22

1070

1152

1155

286

27

112

430

1306

1265

1416

641

711

1085

1345

629
938
768



Daniels v. X. Y., N. H. & H. R. R.

Co. 276

Davis V. Carey 793
Davis V. Guarnieri; Owen, C. J. in, 1362

Dawkins v. Rokeby 1039

Deane v. Clayton 380

Delaney v. Errickson 524

Deminico v. Craig 1224

Derry v. Flitner 251



Page

Devlin v. Smith 519

Dickenson v. Watson 55

Directors, etc., v. Kisch 763

Disbrow v. Tenbroeck 160

Dolan V. Chicago, etc., R. R. Co. 1331

Domina Regina f. Watts 364

Doolittle & Sherman •:'. Shaw 164

Duffy V. Sable Iron Works 400

Dwyer v. Esmonde 1062



Earl V. Van Alstine 540
Eastern & South African Telegraph

Co. V. Tramways Co. 595
Eastern Kentucky Ry. Co. -•. Powell 391
Eastin v. Bank of Stockton 1017
Eckert v. Long Island R. R. Co. 345
Eckert v. Long Island R. R. Co. 1350
Edgington z\ Fitzmaurice 679
Edmondson f. Birch & Co. 1145
Eikhoff V. Gilbert 1137
Ekins V. Tresham 765
Elliott V. Hall 481
Ely V. Stannard 778
Enfield v. Colburn 780
Engel V. Eureka Club 646
Ertz V. Produce Exchange of Minne-
apolis 1278
Exton V. Central R. R. Co. of New
Jersey 205



V. Fakenham 900

Fahr v. Hayes 1158
Fairchild v. McMahon 745
Farrar v. Rollins HI
Filburn v. People's Palace & Aqua-
rium Co. 537
Fitzherbert de Natura Brevium 231
Fitzherbert de Nova Natura Brevium 306
Fitzherbert, Natura Brevium 308
Fitzherbert's Natura Brevium 307
Fitzpatrick v. Cumberland Glass Mfg.

Co. 414
Fitzsimons & Connell Co. v. Braun &

Fitts 609

Fletcher -v. Rylands 559

Forward v. Adams 818

Foster v. Charles 671

Fouldes V. Willoughby 139

Fowler v. Homer 1099

Fox V. Broderick 838

Frazier v. Turner -63

French v. Grand Trunk Ry. Co. 1390

Fritz V. Hobson 1287



Galbraith v. Fleming

Galena & Chicago, etc., R. R. Co. v.

Jacobs; Breese, J. in,
Gallagher and Mason z. Brunei



78



eC3



TABLIi OF CASES.



XIX



1187

98

737

756

1253

40

965

145

393
150
931



H.



Hadcock v. Osmer
Hagee v. Grossman
Halberstadt -■. New York Life Ins.

Co.
Hammersmith, etc., Ry. Co. i'. Brand
Hannabalson v. Sessions
Hanson v. Globe Newspaper Co.
Hardcastle t. South Yorkshire Ry.,

etc., Co.
Harding v. Phila. Rapid Transit Co.
Harris v. Saunders
Harrison z: Berkley
Harrison z: Bush
Harrower f. Ritson
Hartford f. Brady
Harvey v. Young

Haverly v. State Line, etc., R. R. Co.
Hawkins f. Hoffman
Hayn, Roman & Co. z: Culliford
Hazelton z: Week
Healey v. Ballantine & Sons
Heaven v. Pender
Heaven v. Pender
Hebditch z: !McIhvaine
Elellwig z: IMitchell
Hemmens z\ Halstead
Herrick z'. Wixom



717
776

999

1320

38

855

374

1349
113
232

1067
941
532
741
258
110
321
64
552
189
472

1150
790

1074
388



Pace
Gallagher v. Dodge 1301

Gallagher v. Humphrey 416

Clalvin v. Mayor of New York 296

tiaring ;•. I'raser 972

Ciarret ;•. Taylor 1179

Gassett z: Gilbert 1058

George z'. Blow 881

(jeorge v. Skivington SIS

(Jerard v. Dickenson 1059

Geraty v. Stern 26

Germolus z: Sausser 894

Gibbons i'. Pepper 45

Giles f. Walker 363

Gill V. Middleton 467

Glamorgan Coal Co. Miners' Feder-
ation 1192 j

Glassey v. Worcester, etc.. Street Ry.
Co. 292

Glenn v. Winters 488

Goldfield Mines Co. ;■. Miners' Union
No. 220

Gordon v. Harper

Gormely v. Gymnastic Association

(irafFenstein z: Epstein & Co.

tiraham v. St. Charles Street R. R.
Co.

Graves v. Severens

Grove "v. Van Duyn

Gude Co. z>. Farley

Guinn v. Delaware & Atlantic Tele-
phone Co.

Gurley v. Armstead

Gyre v. Culver



Herring z: Boyle

Hills V. Snell

Hindman z: First National Bank

Hoag !■. Lake Shore, etc., R. R. Co.

Holbrook z<. Morrison

Hollins V. Fowler

Holmes v. Drew

Homer z: Battyn

Honey v. Chicago, B. & Q. Ry. Co.

Horan f. Byrnes

Houlden v. Smith

Humphrey z'. Merriam

Hunt z: Star Newspaper Co.

Hupfer f. National Distilling Co.

Hiiset z: Case Threshing Machine Co.

Huskie z: Griffin

Hyde v. Noble



I.



I. de S. et ux v. W. de S.

Indermaur z: Dames

Indianapolis Traction & Terminal Co.

V. Croly
Iowa Central Ry. Co. z'. Walker
Ireland f. McGarvish
Iron Moulders' Union z: Allis-Cham-

bers Co.



J.



Jackson v. Smithson; Piatt, B. in,

Jackson z'. Stanfield

Jersey City Printing Co. v. Cassidy

Johns -■. Marsh

Jones z\ Hulton & Co.

Jones -■. Littler.

Judd z: Walker



Karges Furniture Co. v. Amalgamated

Union
Keeble f. Hickeringill
Kelly f. Henry Muhs Co.
Kemp z: Division No. 241
Key worth -■. Hill
Kimball z\ Bangs
Kimball z: Post Publishing Co.
Kimber z\ Young

King V. Vicksburg Ry. & Light Co.
Klumph V. Dunn
Knowles -•. Richardson
Krebs Z'. Oliver
Kreiner z'. Straubmiiller
Kruse v. Rabe



Pace

84

105

732
244

1305

115

429

23

1429

1299
963
775

1131
444
498

1226
132



10
437

140?

1385
805

1238



537

1261

1179

1031

861

813

766



1191
1176

357
1197

101

741
1106

704
1330

797
1290
1093

39:
1142



Lanark f. Dougherty; Magruder, J.

in, 1373

Lancaster ;■. Hamburger 1156

Lane - . Atlantic Works 288



XX



TABLE OF CASES.



Learoyd v. Godfrey

Leger v. Warren

Le Lievre z\ Gould

Lenahan v. Pittston Coal Co.

Leroy Fibre Co. v. Chicago, etc., R.

R. Co.
Letts v. Kessler
Lewis and Herrick v. Chapman
Lewis V. Hoover

Liming t. Illinois Central Ry. Co.
Liming v. Illinois Central Ry. Co.
Lipe V. Blackwelder
Loader v. London, etc.. Commission
London Guarantee Co. v. Horn
Longmeid z\ Holliday
Loop c'. Litchfield
Losee v. Buchanan
Lumby v. Allday
Lumley v. Gye
Lynch v. Knight
Lynch v. Nurdin



M.



Page
427
985
190

1375

1352

1290

1075

43

348.

1350

908'

319

1249

494

508

598

803

1168

214

395



Macauley Bros. v. Tierney

MacCarthy v. Young

Mackintosh v. Dun

Macon & Augusta R. R. v. Mayes

Madras Ry. Co. v. Zemindar of Car-

vatenagarum
Malachy v. Soper
Managers of Metropolitan Asylum

District v. Hill
Marshall v. Caledonian Ry. Co.
Marshall v. Kansas City, etc., R. R.

Co.
;Marshall v. York, etc., Ry. Co.
Martin v. Houck

Mattauch v. Walsh Bros. & Miller
Mayer v. Walter
McCaskill v. Elliot
McCreadie v. Thomson
McCune v. Norwich City Gas Co.
McDonald v. Sun Printing Co.
McDougall V. Claridge
McDowall V. (jreat Western Ry. Co.
McEntee v. New Jersey Steamboat Co.
McGee v. Willing
McGonigle v. Belleisle Co.
Mcllvoy V. Cockran
McKay v. Pearson
McKenzie v. Cheetham
McNary v. Chamberlain
McPherson v. Daniels
Medbury v. Watson
Metcalf V. Times Publishing Co.
Minasian v. Osborn
Mintzer v. Hogg
Mitchell t: Rochester Ry. Co.
Mitchil V. Alestree
Mogul S. S. Co. V. McGregor
Mohr V. Williams
Monroe v. Hartford Street Ry. Co.



1257
469

1078
625

591
873

1324
294

156

322

28

748

1036

549

959

1276

1127

1065

200

173

61

148

903

102

459

186

839

750

1109

1222

373

281

188

1241

73

1433



Moore v. Inhabitants of Abbot

Morris v. Piatt

Morrison v. Commonwealth

Morrison v. Ritchie & Co.

Morse v. Times-Republican Printing

Co.
Mulgrave v. Ogden
Muller V. M'Kesson
Munns v. Dupont
Murphey v. Caralli



N.



Page
226
896
901

850

1097

109

1363

1024

204



Nash V. Minnesota Title Ins. & Trust

Co. 715
Nehring v. Connecticut Co.; Wheeler,

J. in, 1410

Nelson T. Crawford 21

Newsom t'. Anderson 68

Newton z: Harland 920

Newton v. Weaver 1035
New York, L. E. & W. R. R. Co. v.

New Jersey Elec. Co. 1420

Nichols z: Marsland 582
Nieboer v. Detroit Elec. Co.; Moore,

J. in, 1361

Nitro-Glycerin Case; The, 70
Nonpareil Cork Mfg. Co. v. Keasbey

& Mattison Co. 1124

Norvell V. Thompson 44

O.

Obier v. Neal 901
O'Brien v. Marquis of Salisbury;

Field, J. in, 1139

Ogden V. Claycomb 899

Osborne z: London, etc., Ry. Co. 342

Over z: Schiffling 1159

Oxford V. Leathe 462



Building Trades



P.



Palmer v. Goldberg

Palmer v. Gordon

Palmer v. Northern Pacific R. R. Co.

Palmore v. Morris, Tasker & Co.

Parker t'. Barnard

Parkinson Co. v.

Council
Parson Prick's Case
Parry v. Smith
Pasley ■;'. Freeman
Patterson z: Nutter
Pattison v. Jones
Pearson v. Lord Mayor of Dublin
Peck V. Tribune Co.
Peek V. Derry
Pennsylvania Co. v. Roy
Pennsylvania R. R. Co. v.
Pennyman -'. Rabanks
Pfeiffer v. Grossman
Philadelphia & Reading R.

Ervin



Hope



R. Co. V.



707
386
193
454
361

1228

1153

522

657

947

1096

769

828

691

620

255

877

36

359



TABLE OF CASES.



XXI



Page

Picard v. McCormicl^ 742

Pickett V. Walsh 1210

Pierce v. Staljlemen's Union 1238

Pillow V. Bushnell 72

Pinoza V. Northern Chair Co. 1376

Platz V, Cohoes 1442

Ploof V. Putnam 916

Pluckwell V. Wilson 1360

Plumer v. Harper 451

Phimmer v. Dill; Knowlton, J. in, 430

Polhill V. Walter 673

Pomeroy v. Westfielcl 337

Pottstown Gas Co. v. Murphy 1338

Powell V. Sadler 155

Purcell V. St. Paul City Ry. Co. 279



Q.



Quartz Hill Mining Co. v. Eyre 1011

R.

Radley v. London, etc., Ry. Co. 1378

Railroad Co. v. Reeves 263

Ratcliflfe v. Evans 888

Ravenga v. Mackintosh 1028.

Razor V. Kinsey 48

Reid V. Mitchell 79

Richardson z'. Gunby 871

Ripy V. Cronan 758

Robbins v. Jones 368

Rosewell v. Prior 456

Rude V. Nass 1081

Rumney v. Worthley 836

Rush V. Buckley 987

Russell V. Irby 67

Ryan v. N. Y. C. R. R. Co. 252

Ryan v. Towar 403



Sadlier v. New York; Gaynor, J. in, 1329

Safford V. Grout 772
Salt Springs National Bank v.

Wheeler 108

Samples v. Carnahan 1095

Sanders v. Teape and Swan 528
Sanford v. Pawtucket Street R. R.

Co. 649

Savile V. Roberts; Holt, C. J. in, 1017

Sawyer z; Davis 1338

Sawyer v. Prickett 676

Schofield -c'. Ferrers • 1032
Scholfield Gear & Pulley Co. v. Schol-

field 709

Schubert v. Clark Co. 503

Schultz V. Frankfort Insurance Co. 831

Schutt V. Adair 1373

Schwarcz -z: Garment Workers' Union 1208

Scott V. Shepherd 266

Scott r. Stansfield 1037

Scribner t: Kelley 543



Pace

Seaman v. Nctherclift 104_'

Sharrer v. Paxson 1450

Sheridan v. Bean 530

Sherwood v. Salmon 761

Simmons v. Sykes 153

Singer Mfg. Co. v. King 169

Six Carpenters' Case; The, 87

Skeffington v. Eylward 1025

Smith V. Chadwick 670
Smith V. Land & House Property

Corporation 739

Smith T. London, etc., Ry. Co. 239

Smith V. Stone 50

Smithwick v. Hall & Upson Co. 1445
Sneesby v. Lancashire, etc., Ry. Co. 274

Southcote 'c'. Stanley 434
South Royalton Bank i: Suffolk Bank 1033

Spear v. Alexander 171

State V. Church 16

State V. Davis 11

State V. Evenson 892

State V. Lewis 977

State V. Morgan 13

Statham-Abridgment 306

Steinmetz f. Kelly 1364

Stevens v. O'Neill 82

Stone V. Knapp 91

Storrs V. Utica 614

Sullivan v. Creed 207

Sullivan v. Jones 970

Swain v. Johnson 1174

Swayne v. Rogers 9
Sweeny v. Old Colony, etc., R. R.

Co. 422

Sweet V. Post Publishing Co. 1115

Swift V. Rounds 686

Syeds v. Hay 158



Tarry v. Ashton 630

Taylor v. Hearst £53

Taylor v. Home Telephone Co. 135C

Teakle v. San Pedro, etc., R. R. Co. 1387

Tellefsen v. Fee 993

Terwilliger v. Wands 820

Thomas v. Quartermaine 331
Thomas v. Quartermaine; Bowen, L.

J. in, 1,!60
Thomas v. Quartermaine; Lord Esher,

M. R. in, 1361

Thomas v. Winchester 510

Thompson v. Lowell, etc., Ry. Co. 633

Thorley v. Lord Kerry fi2n

Thorogood v. Bryan 1412

Thrussell f. Handyside 339

Tindle v. Birkett 727

Toogood V. Spyring 11-^0

Toothaker v. Conant 1165

Towanda R. R. v. Munger 528

Trask z: Shotwell 443

Trow -'. Vermont Central R. R. Co. 1394

Tubervil f. StarHp 558



XXI 1



TABLE OF CASES.



Pace
Tuckachinsky r. Lehigh, etc., Coal Co. 605
Turner z\ Stallibrass 328

Tuttle z: Atlantic City R. R. Co. 271

Tuttle z: Buck 1280

U.



Ulrick I'. Dakota Loan & Trust Co.
Underbill r. Hernandez
Union Pacific Ry. Co. z'. Cappier
Union Stock Yards & Transit Co.

Rourke
United States v. Ortega
Urtz V. N. Y. C. & H. R. R. R. Co.



Van Tassel v. Capron

Varney z'. Curtis

Vaughan v. Menlove

Veazie v. Penobscot R. R. Co.

Vicars v. Wilcocks

Vincent z'. Lesney

Virtue v. Birde

Vizetelly v. Mudie's Library

Vosburg V. Putney

Vredenburg z: Behan



W.



Wahl z: Walton
Walker v. Cronin



261
955
302

377

23

781



807
129
194
618
283
107
1344
843
46
543



984
183



Ward z: Ayre

Warner v. Peoples' Street Ry. Co.
Warren v. Manchester Street Ry. Co.
Washington & Ceorgetown R. R. Co.

V. Hickey
Wason V. Walter
Watson V. Rinderknecht
Weaver v. Ward

Weitzman v. Nassau Elec. R. R. Co.
Wells V. Cook
Western Counties Manure Co. v.

Lawes Manure Co.
Wilkinson v. Downton
Willcutt & Sons Co. v. Driscoll
Willelmus de Estre v. Rogerum de

Sancto Dionisio
Willey V. Carpenter
Wilson V. Dubois
Wimple V. Patterson
Winterbottom z'. Wright
Wintringham t'. Lafoy
Wolf z'. Des Moines
Wood z'. Cummings
Wright V. Lothrop
Wyandot Club Co. v. Sells



Y,



Yeager v. Wallace
Yelding z: Fay



Pace
1344
1393
1424

223
1101

229

46

1408

722

884

221

1213

95

77
879
708
490

42
365

49
1046
1317



137

307



LIST OF ESSAYS



Ames, James Barr,



Baldwin, Simeon E.,
BoHLEN, Francis H.,



« "



« «



<t «



<< «



« II



II II



Bracken, Francis B.,

BuRDicK, Francis M.,
Freund, Ernst,
GooDNow, Frank J.,



Hall, Henry C, and
John H. Wigmore.
Hall, Prescott F.,

Holmes, Oliver Wendell,
Huffcut, Ernest W.,



"The Disseisin of Chattels," 3 Harv. L. R. 23, 313,