Poole, William W July 13
Post, Mrs. Nellie M July 13
Potter, Lela L May 17
Powell, Emma J. ...January 27
Power, Marvin December 13
Powers, Mattie K January 27
147
Educatioxai, Diplomas— Continued.
Kames.
Expires.
Powers, AmosM _. - November 11
Powers, Mrs. S. S i December 10
Pratt, Abbie E... â– July 13
Prav, Mattie J. i.-September 29
Price, Thomas S : July 16
Price, W. H July 13
Pringle, Miss Nellie Januar}' 11
Provost, Lottie E. ! June 13
Pullen, S. J : June 12
Purvis, H. Jennie Phelps December 5
Pagan, Denis F July Ifi
Eager, George "W January 27
Ragsdale, Mary January 27
Raines, John W. August 9
Rains, J. L - - January 27
Rambo, Anna July 13
Ramsey, Will C. December 16
Ranev, Addie - .December 30
Ranev, Oren X - May 29
Ransdell, Violante S April 1
Raphael. Pauline - . August 20
Raymond, JSIary J September 26
Ravmond, Kate June 13
Ready, R. W April 23
Reardon, William H.. December 9
Reasoner, Anna S May 17
Rees, Alma July 1
Reese, John W. [...November 6
Regal, Judsou August 20
Re?an, Josie J 1 Julv 16
Reilly, Michael J July 13
Remington, Carrie L August 9
Reynolds, Morell May 1
Reynolds, S. K January 27
Reynolds, Miss E. W ... November 1
Richards, George C July 13
Richardson, Clara C February-9
Richardson, Irene December 16
Richardson, Noble A ' August 9
Richardson, George A ' June 13
Riehl, Kate M July 16
Richmond, Hiram H May 17
Riley, Ella September 29
Rilev, James A ' June 13
Rilev, John T i June 13
Riley, Peter T.. ; June 13
Ring, William C - - November 3
Ritter, C. M Mavl7
Roache, Mrs. Edith Z July 28
Robbins, Philomene January 17
Roberts, Mary E. July 16
Roberts, Carrie W . . ; January 27
Robinett, Margaretta M October 13
Robinson, Mary J August 9
Robinson, Emma F August 20
Roche, Anna J. . ' January 27
Rockwood, Josephine January 27
Rogers, William November 6
Rogers, Emma J — .December 17
Rogers, Isabella April 1
Roice, Edward A ! July 13
Roice,Ruth !... November 7
Ronald, James T. â– June 13
Root, George E. December 16
Root. Alice M August 20
Root, Ellis J Januarv 27
Root, Mattie E July II
148
Educatiosal Diplomas — Continued.
Names.
Expires.
Roper, Belinda I August 20
Rose, John D July 16
Rosenberg, Frances M July 16
Ross, Mrs. Martlia M. August 20
Rountree, Eva L. December 30
Rowe, Marv E. July 16
Rowell, Edward P June 13
Rubell,C. F July 9
Ruddock, Benjamin J May 1
Ruddock, Mrs. Kate January 27
Russell, F. P July 11
Russell, Mrs. L. A August 20
Russell. Sadie E January 27
Rutherford, Marv A. - — July 9
Ryder, J. Scott. I July 13
Sabin. Minnie E. August 9
Said. Ellii April 30
Salcido, Manuela June 12
Sally, Mary June 13
Sample, Emma . July 16
Sanborn, Allan P December 11
Sargent, Miss Lizzie Xovenjber 1
Saunders, Wesley December 5
Savage, Myron H February 26
Saxton, Mary L July 14
Schaeggs. Amv C. V - - November 1
Schafer. A. C." October 13
Scott, H. W. November 6
Scott, Maggie K April 16
Scott, Mrs. Modena J. April 1
Scrivner, Rosa L November 3
Sears, Sadie L. July 13
Seavey, Mabel January 27
Seeley. Nettie B. Decembe'r 30
Seelev, Eliza A. â– January 27
Selling, Nathalie A. June 13
Seward, R. V December 18
Seward, Frank D. April 16
Sexton, Caroline M. August 9
Seymour, Mrs. E. M. November 22
Shaner, J. J. November 13
Shaw. Mattie J. November 6
Shea, Mary T .January 27
Shearer. Flora M. January 27
Shelly, Emma December 16
Shepiieard, Kate July 13
~' â– " ~ .. August 20
- August 20
November 6
July 13
.April 1
Shepard, Lucv R
Shepard, Addle C
Sherman, Julia E
Short. Montgomery L
Shrack, Blanche
Shuck, Hermine *.-. March 17
Simmons, R. .J .â– December 30
Simon, Minna May 1
Simon, John H
Simonds, Fred. W
Simpson, George W.
Sinclair, Mary W.
Sisson, William H.
Skahaen, Hannah
Slaven, Thomas D. M.
Slo-ss, Miss Dora ; March 19
Smallfield, Alice I July 16
Smelizer, Manassas J. July 13
Smith, Georgia May 1
Smith, Eleanor M i February 9
Smith, Ina E ...I May 17
July 13
_- August 9
-.June 12
January 27
.- August 9
_- August 9
July 16
149
Educational Diplomas — Continued.
Expires.
Smith, Cora V
Smith, Florence
Smith, S.Clark
Smith, Misf5 Carrie L
Smith, Joseph
Smith, Edward P
Smith, J. W
Smith, Annie E
Smith, Miss Julia
Smith, Virginia E
Smyth, Jennie
Smyth, Anna
Smvthe, E. Louisa
Smullen, S. N. D
Snedaker, Eunice I
Sniffen, Mrs. Jennie B. ._
Snow, Melvin
Solomon, Mrs. Hanna M.
Somerset, Clara
Sowle, Etta
Spalding, Harriet A
Spaulding, Timothy A. ..
Spiers, Jennie C.
Sprague, Abbie F.
Spurrier, Charles A.
Squires, Ida ..
Stallman, Nettie C
Stanfield, Annie
Stanford, Belle M
Stanley, Hartwell B
Steele," Mattie E.
Stephenson, John
Stern, Augusta
Steves, Ada
Stevens, Miss Eliza
Stewart, James A
Stewart, Jesse M
Stewart, Mrs. M. C
Stewart, Benjamin F
Stiles, S. A.."
Stiner, Jessie
Stockton, L. D
Stone, Nettie
Stone, Ethel C
Stone, Helen M
Stone, Marion P.
Stone, Hannah E.
Stone, Mary G
Stout, George H.
Stout, Lizzie W
Storj'', Lizzie
Stowell, Fred. W.
Strange, Jennie
Strauss, Ida R.
Stringfield, James
Stuart, Mrs. Franc E
Subors, Sadie A
Sullivan, C. G
Sullivan, Nellie F.
Sullivan, D. J
Sullivan, Miss Nora G
Sullivan, Mrs. Theresa M.
Summerville, Letitia
Swain, Lizzie W
Swank, Ida M
Swanson, J. T.
Swasey, Alice
- July 13
- January 27
September 19
November 10
. November fi
. November 6
November 12
May28|
June 2
September 25
August 9
JulvlB
July 16
-. January 27
July 13
-December 23
- November 3
August 20
May 17
August 9
September 19
April 2
July 11
-December 16
-December 16
April 1
April 1
May 17
-December 16
.-. Januarj - 27
July 16
. November 25
August 9
July 16
July 9
. February 9
July 13
-December 22
July 13
._- January 27
Julv 1
Julyl3
July 16
October 20
-December 15
July 13
August 20
August 20
July 13
-December 16
July 13
-December 16
.-. February 9
April 1
July 13
November 13
July 13
. January 27
- Januarv 27
March 26
May 17
,_. December 8
August 9
July 16
February 9
- December 9
September 11
1888
1887
1888
1885
1886
1886
1885
1885
1885
1885
1890
1889
1889
1887
1888
1885
1889
1887
1890
1890
1888
1885
1885
1888
1888
1888
1888
1890
1888
1888
1889
1885
1890
1889
1885
1890
1886
1885
1888
1887
1885
1886
1889
1885
1885
1886
1887
1887
1888
1888
1888
1888
1890
1888
1888
1885
1888
1887
1888
1885
1885
1884
1890
1889
1890
1885
1885
150
Educational Diplomas — Continued.
Expires.
Sweeney, Cassie L. December 16
Sweeney, Minnie. December 16
Sweeney, Edward May 17
.Svkes, Mrs. Jane N. June 9
Tatham, Jobn December Ifi
Taylor, Mary F December .30
Tavlor, Herbert L. July 16
Taylor, Mary A May 29
Teaford, Mamie W j August 20
Teinpleton, Mrs. Carrie ..- i March 10
Tenbrook, Alice R. { July 16
Terry, Henrv F. . _. September 17
Thayer, Eose 1 July 16
Thorn, C. J - j April 2
Thomas, Flora M November 6
Thomasson, Annie E 1 August 20
Thompson, Albert N - July 13
Thompson, Roberta A July 13
Thompson, William George July 13
Thompson, Miss Helena April 19
Thompson, Sarah November 12
Thompson, Mrs. S. R December 26
Thornton, Miss M. E January 11
Thorp, J. H January 11
Thurston, Hettie December 9
Thyes, Josie _ August 20
Tinning, William . - .December 9
Titchworth, J. C August 25
Titus, Mary J. 1 • February 24
Tobin, Maggie July 16
Todd, Maggie - — July 13
Toll, Sarah J December 17
Tompkins, Cora December 30
Townley, Emma August 20
Towusend. Belle November 5
Trainor, William F. : .- July 13
Trask, Stella G. .' .December 30
Trask, Dummer K. ._. August 9
Traynor, Marv E April 1
Turner, Hattie E April 1
Turner, Mrs. Hannah Scott ; August 20
Turner, Belle J December 31
Tuttle, Marv E ..-July 16
Tuttle, Mary E May 17
Twombly, B. H - November 21
Tyler, Mrs. Eliza.. January 27
Tyrrell, Mary A I January 27
Udell, Mrs. Frances M. j.. September 17
Underwood, George | May 17
Valentine, Louis H. i — December 16
Valentine. Lawton W i July 13
Van Fassen, M. L. .* July 12
Van Gudder, Bertie April 1
Van Guilder, Hutie November 3
Variel, Mrs. Carrie L June 13
Varcoe, George August 9
Varnach, Mrs. E. P _. February 12
Vestal, Mrs. Sallie H L October 29
Vickers, Edward May 17
Vickers, Isora August 20
Vivian, Callie C .- July 16
Vivian, T. J December 16
Vollmar, Bertha T Novembers
Vrooman, Charles M February 9
Wade, Mrs. Ada.. January 27
Wade, Nettie December 16
Wadleigh, Mary N November 29
151
Educational Diplomas — Continued.
Expires.
Wagner, Lizzie 1 August 9
Walden, Mrs. Alice C. I June 13
Waklron.Miss Helen R. j May 21
Walker, C.M - 1 July 9
Walker, Clara M 1.. September 11
Walker, Christopher 1— September 19
Walker, Cornelia I March 12
Walker, Marv E 1 July 16
Walker, E. H ; April 19
Walker, Charles J I April 1
Walker, Mrs. Lucy Anna I April 1
Wallace, Emma.. '< August 9
Wallace, J. T September 29
Wallis, Florence L October 14
Walsh, Mary V -June 13
Walters, Cvnthia N December 30
Walton, M'iss A. E — JiTovember 20
Ward, Alice B November 1
Ward, Thomas B November 6
Ward, S. L : April 5
Ward, Fannv '. .—April 1
Ward, Ida M i August 20
Warfield, Marv C- j August 9
Waring, Marv' May ' May 17
Warnich, James W ;...... .April 23
Warren, Miss Anna June 22
Warren, George Waters -. ..-' December 5
Wash, Mrs. F. L ; October 29
Waterburv, Lizzie [ May 1
Watkins, Kate F August 9
Watson, N. Flotella. i July 18
Weatherwax, Bertha — ! July 9
Webb, Nellie : - - November 3
Webb, Mrs. Mary E December 7
Webber, F. E L. .February 22
Webster, Frankee _. .December 30
Webster, Calvin B ! January 27
Weed, Ida B | July 16
Weed, Alice ; January 27
.May 10
.July 16
-July 13
Weeks, Miss Annie C
Weinmann, Louis
Welch, Eliza G. ..
Welch, Alice ' November 3
Weldon, Lillian S j January 27
Wells, Alice M ..' July 13
Wells, George S i Tune 13
Wells, Harry Clayton. â– June 13
Wells, James L- September 17
Welton, A. T |.-. February 22
Wentworth, Augusta M. ' December 30
West, A. C ...I May 7
Weston, Augusta ' August 9
Westerfield, J. F ; - . November 5
Wharton, Zachariah F ' August 20
Wheatou, Ann S i January 22
Wheatou, Miss Clara I March 26
Wheelock, Dorcas May 14
White, Richard ! July 16
White, Nicholas [ May 17
White, Clarence M . January 4
White, Mrs. Martha E i August 20
White, Mrs. Sara — j April 19
White, Mary F 1 July 13
Whitehurst, Sarah F | July 16
Whitmore, John H. 1 July 13
Whittemore, Benj. F L. September 17
152
Educational Diplomas — Continued.
Expires.
Whiltenmever, Clara K. .-.
Wilber, Mrs. M. C
Wilkins, Kate M
"Wilkinson, Joseph
Wilkinson, Mrs. Anita
Willard, Miss R. C
Williams, Mary E
Williams, A. E
Williamson, Emily L
Wilson, Delia R
Wilson, Julia F
Wilson, Ella F
Willis, William L
Wilson, J. L
Wilson, MaryE
Wilson, Henry
Winchester, Mrs. W. H
Wing, Flor nee D
Wise, Charles T
Wiseman, Mary L.
Witherow, Samuel N
Wood, E.Alfaretta
Wood, Jacob H. __
Wood, M.Dallas
Wood, Susie
Woodman, Charles A
Woods, Miss Bettie
Woods, C. H 1
Woodward, Albert Pearson
Woodward, M. W
Woodward, F.J
Wooster, Carrie E
Worth, Mrs. L. G.
Worthen, Mrs. M. J
Worthing, Warren
Wright, Mrs. Ada E
Wright, Mrs. M. S
Wright, Emily Vose
Wright, Martin V
Wyllie, A. L
Yager, Mymn
Yaffer, Myron fduplicate) -
Yates, T. M.._J
York, Cora A.
Yorke, Jennie H
YouuEC, W. H
Young, Mary A
Young, Thomas L
Young, Mrs. Belle
Young, Rachel
Younger, Maggie
Youngman, Miss A. M.
Yount, Thomas J.
Zumwalt, Mrs.V. P. S
Z wicker, Kate
_- January 27,
- November 2,
-December 16,
-December 16,
November 18,
- January 27,
_- January 27,
November 18,
- November 3,
-December 30,
July 16,
-. February 9,
July 16,
-.December 9,
November 26,
-. -October 27,
-December 18,
.Julv 16.
July 16,
,_ . January 27,
May 29,
July 16,
. September 19,
. - Januarv 27,
Julyl,
May 10,
March 19,
. - January 27,
._. Januar}' 27,
..- February 8,
. November 26,
May 17,
April 30,
July 13,
May 17,
July 7,
May 29,
April 1,
. - December 9,
... January 27,
.-December 18,
July 16,
October 17,
May 17,
.- November 3,
March 22,
July 9,
. - November 3,
August 20,
. September 19,
June 12,
April 23,
May 17,
.-December 10,
. - January 27,
153
STATEMENT OF EXPENDITURES.
I hereby certify that I have expended, out of the appropriations
for this office, the following :
Thiety-Fourth Fiscal Year, Ending June 30, 1883.
Contingent expenses S43 70. Amount on hand at taking office S49 10
Postage and expressage 336 10. Amount on hand at taking office 419 50
Traveling expenses 283 55. Amount on hand at taking office 293 70
Thirty-Fifth Fiscal Year, Ending June 30, 1884.
Contingent expenses S91 14. Amount of appropriation $100 00
Postage and expressage 378 55. Amount of appropriation 1,200 00
Traveling expenses 1,000 00. Amount of appropriation 1,000 00
Besides this, there is a deficiency claim of $40 95 in traveling expenses for 1884, all of which,
in items, will more fully appear by vouchers, laid before the State Board of Examiners, and
now in the Controller's office.
WM. T. WELCKER,
Superintendent of Public Instruction.
State of California, ' )
County of Sacramento. J
I, William T. Welcker, Superintendent of Public Instruction, do swear that the above is a
true statement of the expenditures of the appropriations for the office of Superintendent of
Public Instruction of the State of California, except salaries, from January 8, 1883, to
June 30, 1884.
WM. T. WELCKER,
Superintendent of Public Instruction.
Subscribed and sworn to before me, this twenty-second day of September, 1884.
W. S. LEAKE,
Deputy Clerk uf Supreme Court.
II-
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA,
BIENNIAL REPORT
PRESIDENT OF THE UNIVERSITY
ON BEHALF OF THE BOARD OF REGENTS,
His Excellency the Governor of the State.
1882-84.
SACRAMENTO:
STATE OFFICE JAMES J. AYERS, SUPT. STATE PRINTING.
1884.
REPORT.
To his Excellency George Stoneman, Governor of the State of California:
In accordance with, the requirement of Section 1432 of the Political
Code, I have the honor of herewith submitting, in behalf of the Board
of Regents of the University of California, the following biennial
report upon the University for the academic years 1882-83 and 1883-
84, namely: from August 1, 1882, to August 1, 1884.
I have included in the report such statistics of the present year,
and of previous years, as seemed to me likely to throw light upon the
present condition and prospects of the University.
Itistimction.
The Board of Regents has organized the following named colleges
and regular courses leading to a degree: At Berkeley, a College of
Letters, a College of Agriculture, a College of Mechanics, a College of
Mining, a College of Civil Engineering, a College of Chemistry, a
Literary Course, and a Course in Letters and Political Science; in
San Francisco, a College of Law, a College of Medicine, a College of
Dentistry, and a College of Pharmacy. Besides these colleges and
regular courses, the organic Act creating the University declares that
" each college shall have a partial course for those who may not desire
to pursue a full course therein; and any resident of California, of
the age of fourteen years or upwards, of approved moral character,
shall have the right to enter himself in the University as a student
at large, and receive tuition in any branch or branches of instruction,
at the time when the same are given in their regular course, on such
terms as the Board of Regents may prescribe."
Faculties, and other Officers of histruction.
The organic Act defines the Faculty of a college to be " the President
and resident professors of the same."'
Li 1882-83 the Faculties of the colleges at Berkeley consisted of the
President and eleven resident professors. There were connected with
these Faculties three honorary professors, thirteen instructors, one
assistant instructor, two lecturers, one assistant in chemistry, and one
assistant in agricultural chemistry.
The Faculty of the Hastings College of the Law consisted of the
President and three professors.
The Faculty of the Toland College of Medicine consisted of the
President and eleven professors. There were connected with this
Faculty one lecturer, and one demonstrator and assistant lecturer.
The Faculty of the College of Dentistry consisted of the President
and seven professors. There were connected with this Faculty four
demonstrators and nine clinical instructors.
The Faculty of the College of Pharmacy consisted of the President
and four professors.
In 1883-84 the Faculties of the colleges at Berkeley consisted of the
President and fourteen resident professors. There were connected
with these Faculties three honorary professors, twelve instructors, one
assistant instructor, one temporary instructor, two lecturers, one
assistant in chemistry, one assistant in agricultural chemistry, and
one superintendent of the machine shop.
The Faculty of the Hastings College of the Law consisted of the
President, two professors, and the Dean.
The Faculty of the Toland College of Medicine consisted of the
President and thirteen professors.
The Faculty of the College of Dentistry consisted of the President
and seven professors. There were connected with this Faculty three
demonstrators, two assistant demonstrators, and thirteen clinical
instructors.
The Faculty of the College of Pharmacy consisted of the President
and four professors.
Academic Senate.
The organic Act defines the Academic Senate to be " all the Facul-
ties and instructors of the University." It further says of the
Academic Senate that "every person engaged in instruction in the
University, whether resident professors, non-resident professors, teach-
ers, or instructors, shall have permission to participate in its discus-
sions; but the right of voting shall be confined to the President and
the resident and non-resident professors."
In 1882-83 the Academic Senate consisted of the President of the
University, thirty-nine professors, twenty-two instructors, two assist-
ant instructors, three lecturers, and five demonstrators.
In 1883-84 it consisted of the President, thirty-nine professors, the
Dean of the Hastings College of the Law, twenty-five instructors, one
assistant instructor, one temporary instructor, two lecturers, three
demonstrators, and two assistant demonstrators.
There appear to be serious incongruities in the constitution of the
Faculties and the Academic Senate. The most striking, perhaps, is
the provision that admits an instructor to a seat with the Academic
Senate and gives him a voice in its discussions, but does not accord
him either a seat or a voice in the Faculty of the college in which he
gives instruction. He is, in other words, given a seat and a hearing
with the body to which he can be of little or no service, and deprived
of a seat and a voice with the body with which he is associated in all
his duties, and to which the information and the counsel that he could
give would often be of the greatest value.
There are other incongruities more serious in their consequences,
one of which is so marked as to deserve special attention.
It may be stated as a matter of history that for several years there
were no professional colleges connected with the University, and the
Faculties at Berkeley, therefore, constituted the Academic Senate.
The duties they had long performed related entirely to the colleges
at Berkeley, and as the addition of the afUliated colleges introduced
no new questions into their deliberations, they still continued by
common consent in the exercise of their accustomed powers. Indeed,
these powers were so fitting, and so exactly coincided with the powers
assigned to the Academic Senate, that it can hardly be doubted that
it was the intention of the framer of the Act simply to define the
body composed of the joint Faculties at Berkeley. But whatever may
have been his intention, the terms of the Act seem to include the
Faculties of the affiliated colleges as members of the Senate, and
later the Board of Regents so ruled.
The powers of the Academic Senate are defined as follows:
The Senate must conduct the general administration of the University, regulate the general
and special courses of instruction, receive and determine all appeals from acts of discipline
enforced by the Faculty of any college, and exercise such other powers as the Board of Regents
may confer upon it.
A single illustration will make plain the impropriety of lodging
some of the powers here enumerated with the joint Faculties of the
Colleges of Letters and of Science at Berkeley, and of Law, Medicine,
Dentistry, and Pharmacy in San Francisco. It is, for example, the
duty of the Senate to regulate the general and special courses of
study.
This duty imposes upon the Faculties of the undergraduate col-
leges at Berkeley the power to regulate, or to have a voice in regulat-
ing, the courses of instruction in the Colleges of Law, Medicine,
Dentistry, and Pharmacy, and upon the Faculties of the Colleges of
Law, Medicine, Dentistry, and Pharmacy the power to regulate or to
take part in regulating the courses of instruction in the Colleges of
Agriculture, Mechanics, Mining, Civil Engineering, Chemistry, and
Letters, and in the Literary Course and the course in Letters and
Political Science.
The propriety, on the other hand, of placing in the hands of the
joint Faculties at Berkeley the power to regulate their several courses
of study will be plain, if it be borne in mind that there are six under-
graduate colleges and two undergraduate courses at Berkeley, and
that most of the professors and instructors have duties in all, or in
almost all, of them. It cannot, for example, be left to the College of
Letters to call for two hours of Mathematics, to the College of Agri-
culture to call for three, to the College of Chemistry to call for four,
or any other number, and to the remaining colleges and courses to
call for such hours as the several Faculties would be glad to have, for
it would be impossible for the department of Mathematics to meet
these various demands. So of the other departments. If each col-
lege or course had a distinct corps of teachers, so that each could be
independent of everj' other, instead of their being mutually inter-
dependent as they are, the entire aspect of the case would be different.
The Faculties of these several colleges and courses must then
meet as one body, and so coordinate and distribute the work that
each college or course shall receive a due portion of the time that
each professor or department can give.
And what has been said of the community of interest in the matter
of adjusting the work of the several departments of instruction at
Berkeley may also be said of many other matters, and yet the terms
of the organic Act are such that the Board of Regents has felt com-
pelled to decide that the Faculties at Berkeley cannot act as a joint
body in these and other matters affecting in common and exclusively
their own colleges. This unforeseen outcome has entailed extreme
embarrassment upon the Faculties at Berkeley. To do much of the
work that has heretofore been done in a simple and efficient way by
a single meeting of the joint Faculties, it is now necessary, in order
to secure the uniformity of action that is absolutely essential to the
harmonious working of interdependent colleges, to call the joint
Faculties together for deliberation and to formulate a desirable line
of conduct; and then to submit the result of these deliberations to
the six several Faculties for their approval.
Many of the duties placed upon the Academic Senate are important
duties, certainly, but they are not such as belong to an Academic
Senate. That body has, or should have, the greater and more impor-
tant function of determining matters of general university policy; of
proposing measures which, while strengthening each individual de-
partment, shall yet contribute to the strengthening and building up of
the University as a whole. It is not that there are likely to be antag-