Francis Jeffrey Jeffrey.

Selections from the essays of Francis Jeffrey online

. (page 20 of 21)
Online LibraryFrancis Jeffrey JeffreySelections from the essays of Francis Jeffrey → online text (page 20 of 21)
Font size
QR-code for this ebook

tion as to power and civilization to neighbouring countries . . . pre-
vailing occupations . . . soil and climate." Finally, of the influence
of the epoch, Taine says : *' There is yet a third rank of causes ; for,
with the forces within and without, there is the work which they
have already produced together, and this work itself contributes to
produce that which follows. ... It is with a people as with a plant ;
the same sap, under the same temperature, and in the same soil,
produces, at different steps of its progressive development, different
formations, buds, flowers, fruits, seed-vessels, in such a manner that
the one which follows must always be preceded by the former, and
must spring up from its death." All these influences, which Taine
includes under the general name of epoch, correspond precisely to
those that Jeffrey has in mind when he speaks of " the newness or
antiquity" of a society, and of the various stages, through which
nations inevitably pass, in their " progress from rudeness to refine-
ment." In this essay, then, Jeffrey anticipates very strikingly the
points of view, the analysis, and the classification of facts, that Taine
did so much to make popular forty years later, in the Introduction to
his Histoire de la litth'attire anglaise. For Taine's theory see his
History of English Literature, Van Laun's translation. New York,
1891, Introduction. For suggestive criticisms on Taine's position
see Sainte-Beuve, Causer ies du lundi, Paris, 3d ed., XIII, p. 249 ff. ;
Paul Bourget, Essais de psychologic contemporaine, Paris, 1887,
I, p. 180 ff; fimile Hennequin, La critique scientifique, Paris, 1888,
pp. 93-127.

161 31. The Taste of the Nation. The reader should bear in mind
Jeffrey's theory of Beauty, as expounded in the article on the Nature
and P7-inciples of Taste, p. 149 ff. Objects are beautiful according
as they wake in the mind echoes of past passions, — love, hate, pity,
fear, — which have been associated with these objects in actual experi-

NOTES. 211

ence. Now it is at once plain that such widely differing civilizations
as those Jeffrey describes in the text would lead to wide and radical
differences in the associations of pleasure and pain that would cling
about the same object in two different nations. Hence, the same
object would have wholly different aesthetic values for two different
nations. In some such way as this Jeffrey would apply his theory of
Beauty to explain the variations in national standards of Taste.

163 14. On anything so purely accidental. Jeffrey is here not far
from the view of the modern scientific critic, — from that of
Taine, for example. To be sure, Jeffrey regards the character of
Shakspere and the characters of other writers as " on the whole
casual " ; but by this phrase he merely denotes that residuum of
inexplicableness in every individuality that defies the keenest
scientific analysis. Such a residuum remains to-day in spite of all
the advances in physiology and biology, and psychology and
sociology, and in spite of all the talk about heredity and environ-
ment. For Taine, as for Jeffrey, individual character was still
inexplicable, though Taine perhaps brought the " casual " element
within narrower limits than Jeffrey would have believed possible.
The important point to note is that Jeffrey pleads in this essay for a
view of literature that makes it a growth in accordance with law.
Shakspere's poetry, he contends, could not have been produced in
France ; could have been produced only in England. Shakspere's
poetry was therefore determined in character by the miliezi in the
midst of which it was written. Of the nature and degree of the
influence of the epoch Jeffrey is not so sure; and of the influence of
race he has only the vaguest notions. But at least for the time
being, and in theory, he is convinced that literature is something
more than the artificial product of ingenious men, who, in writing
verse and prose, follow idly their own whims and caprices. Cf.

168 8. Peculiarities of German taste. In trying to account for
German taste, Jeffrey considers first those influences that Taine
would group under the term moment, and secondly, those that Taine
would class as milieu. Of course the discussion that follows is
grotesquely inadequate ; it could not fail to be inadequate, inasmuch
as Jeffrey had only the merest smattering of a second-hand knowl-
edge of German literature, and was familiar with German history
only as an intelligent English reader might be familiar with it who
had kept close watch on current European politics. Of German
metaphysics and of German literary criticism Jeffrey was consciously

212 NOTES.

and proudly ignorant. Under these circumstances, his explanation
of German taste was bound to be merely a botch of random guesses,
more or less happy intuitions, and superficially clever generalities.
A few years later Carlyle undertook the same problem with
an altogether different equipment and with altogether different

168 22. They grew tired of bemg respected. It seems strange to
find Jeffrey relapsing here into the superficial view of literature as
merely the work of clever artificers trying to show skill and win
fame. His whole preceding argument has tended to prove that the
literature of any epoch is made what ft is because of its spontaneous
adaptation to the social needs of the times. At least, this is the
interpretation that a modern reader, familiar with the views of Taine
and his school, would put on the opening pages of this essay. The
present passage, however, seems to show that Jeffrey only partly
realized the conclusions to which his arguments lead. His problem
is to explain the characteristics of various periods in German
literature. In trying to solve this problem he does not consider how
the literature of each period corresponded to the social needs of the
time, and gave imaginative expression to. the ideals of life that were
current in the period in question. He considers literature apart
from the life of the times and regards it merely as the work of
" authors " writing for their own delectation or for public applause.
He sees that in their choice of subjects and in their methods of
treatment these authors must have been influenced somewhat by
surroundings and epoch. But his analysis of the nature of this
influence is very unconvincing ; and he does not conceive either of
the life of the German nation or of its expression in the literature of
its authors as an evolution in accordance with law. This essay is
almost the only one where Jeffrey ever attempts to use the historical
method in the study of contemporary literature. His failure here
shows just how far he comprehended and had control of the method
in question. He understood in its main principles the theory on
which the use of the method depends for its justification. He even
applied the method with some success to explain the characteristics
of certain earlier periods of English literature. But in the study of
contemporary literature he never used the method successfully;
partly because he was more interested in judging than in explaining ;
partly because he was not broad enough in his sympathies to enter
into all the conflicting ideals of life and of art that surrounded him ;
partly because he had no adequate conception of society as an

NOTES. 213

organism complex in structure and manifold in functions, and no
clear insight into the subtle interplay of social forces.

169 32. Tristram Shandy . . . Richardson, For a somewhat
similar account of the influence of English models on German
authors of the baser sort, see Coleridge's Biographia Literaria,
Bohn's edition, chap. 23.

170 1. The fantastical speculations of fohti B uncle. Thomas
Amory, the author of The Life offohn Buncle, Esq., was born about
1 691 and died in 1788. He is believed to have known Swift, was at
one time intimate with Toland and other Deists, but later lived
almost a hermit's life, and is thought to have been not quite sane.
The first volume of \i\s, fohn Buncle appeared in 1756, the second in
1766. The work is a strange compound of romantic adventures,
rhapsodies over natural scenery, and theological speculations.
Buncle marries and buries seven wives in the course of his tale, all
of them beautiful creatures whom he chances upon in his peregri-
nations through the English lake region. One noteworthy point in
the book is the author's genuine appreciation of picturesque scenery.
Hazlitt devotes Number 18 of his Round Table to a eulogy of
Amory, whom he calls the English Rabelais. Lamb was also a
reader of Buncle. Cf. his essay on the Two Races of Me ft.

173 I. A very curious . . . work. As the extracts in the text
deal hardly at all with Baber it is not worth while to go into the
details of his life. The extracts have been given because they
express Jeffrey's latest ideas touching the influence of race on
civilization, and because they supplement suggestively the specula-
tions at the beginning of the essay on Wilhelm Meister.

180 16. A natural and ifiherent difference. Cf. 159-7 and 159-11.



M info's Manual of English Prose Literature.

Designed maiuly to show characteristics of style. By William Minxo,
M.A., Professor of Logic and English Literature in the University of
Aberdeen, Scotland. 12mo. Cloth. 566 pages. Mailing price, ^1-65;
for introduction, ^1.50.

rpHE main design is to assist in directing students in English
composition to the merits and defects of the principal writers
of prose, enabling them, in some degree at least, to acquire the one
and avoid the other. The Introduction analyzes style : elements
of style, qualities of style, kinds of composition. Part First gives
exhaustive analyses of De Quincey, Macaulay, and Carlyle. These
serve as a key to all the other authors treated. Part Second takes
up the prose authors in historical order, from the fourteenth cen-
tury up to the early part of the nineteenth.

Hiram Corson, Prof. English Lit-
erature, Cornell University : With-
out going outside of this book, an ear-
nest student could get a knowledge
of English prose styles, based on the
soundest principles of criticism, such
as he could not get in any twenty
volumes which I know of.

Eatherine Lee Bates, Prof, of
English, Wellesley College: It is of
sterling value.

John M. Ellis, Prof, of English
Literature, Obcrlin College : I am
using it for reference with great in-

terest. The criticisms and comments
on authors are admirable — the best,
on the whole, that I have met with
in any text-book.

J. Scott Clark, Prof, of Rhetoric,
Syracuse University : We have now
given Minto's English Prose a good
trial, and I am so much pleased that
I want some more of the same.

A. W. Long, Wofford College, Spar-
tanburg, S.C.: I have used Minto's
English Poets and English Prose the
past year, and am greatly pleased
with the results.

Minto's Characteristics of the English Poets,

from Chaucer to Shirley.

By William Minto, M.A., Professor of Logic and English Literature
In the University of Aberdeen, Scotland. 12mo. Cloth, xi + 382 pages.
Mailing price, $1.65 ; for introduction, $1.50.

nnHE chief objects of the author are: (1) To bring into clear

light the characteristics of the several poets ; and (2) to trace

bow far each w^as influenced by his literary predecessors and his



Selections in English Prose from Elizabeth to

Victoria. 1580-1880.

By James M. Garnett, Professor of the English Language and Liter-
ature in the University of Virginia. 12mo. Cloth, ix + 701 pages.
By mail, $1.65; for introduction, $1.50.

^HE selections are accompanied by such explanatory notes as
have been deemed necessary, and will average some twenty
pages each. The object is to provide students with the texts
themselves of the most prominent wiiters of English prose for
the past three hundred years in selections of sufficient length to
be characteristic of the author, and, when possible, they are com-
plete works or sections of works.

F. B. Gummere, Prof, of English,
Haverford College: I like the plan,
the selections, and the making of the

H. N. Ogden, West Virginia Uni-
versity : Tlie book fulfils my expec-
tations in every respect, and will
become an indispensable help in the
work of our senior English class.

Sidney's Defense of Poesy.

Edited with an Introduction and Notes by Albert S. Cook, Professor
of English in Yale University. 12mo. Cloth, xlv + 103 pages. By
mail, 90 cents ; for introduction, 80 cents.

A S a classic text-book of literary aesthetics, Sidney's Defense has
enduring interest and value. Something of the character of
Sidney as a man, of the grandeur of his theme, of the signifi-
cance of poetry, of sound methods of profiting by poetry and of
judging it, — ought to be disclosed by study of the book. In
the notes everything is considered with reference to the learner,
as far as possible ; and the point of view is not exclusively that
of the grammarian, the antiquary, the rhetorician, or the ex-
plorer of Elizabethan literature, but has been chosen to include
something of all these, and more.

WiUiam Minto, Prof, of Litera-
ture, University of Aberdeen: It
seems to me to be a very thorough
and instructive piece of work. The
interests of the student are consulted
in every sentence of the Introduction
and Notes, and the paper of ques-
tions is admirable as a guide to the
thorough study of the substance of
the essay.

Homer T. Fuller, Pres. Worcester
Polytechnic Institute, Worcester,
Mass. : I think every lover of the
best specimens of good thought and

good writing in our mother tongue
must confess his obligations to both
editor and publishers of such a
volume as this. First, for the breadth
and accuracy of the notes; second,
for the historical research and good
critical judgment displayed in the
introduction; third, for the good
taste and clearness of the type and
print ; and fourth, for the timeliness
of the appearance of a volume which
just at present calls attention to some
of the essentials of poetry.



Shelley's Defense of Poetry.

Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by Albert S. Cook, Professor of
English in Yale University. 12mo. Cloth, xxvi + 86 pages. Price by
mail, 60 cents ; for introduction, 50 cents.

OHELLEY'S Defense may be regarded as a companion-piece to
that of Sidney. In their diction, however, the one is of the
sixteenth century and the other of the nineteenth. For this reason
a comparison of the two is of interest to the student of historical
English style. But, apart from this, the intrinsic merits of Shelley's
essay must ever recommend it to the lover of poetry and of beauti-
ful English. The truth which he perceives and expounds is one
which peculiarly needs enforcement at the present day, and it is
nowhere presented in a more concise or attractive form.

John F. Genung, Prof, of Rhetoric,
Amherst College: By his excellent
editions of these three works, Profes-
sor Cook is doing invaluable service
for the study of poetry. The works
themselves, written by men who were
masters alike of poetry and prose,
are standard as literature; and in

the introductions and notes, which
evince in every part the thorough and
sympathetic scholar, as also in the
beautiful form given to the books by
printer and binder, the student has
11 the help to the reading of them
that he can desire.

Cardinal Newman's Essay on Poetry,

With reference to Aristotle's Poetics. Edited, with Introduction and
Notes, by Albert S. Cook, Professor of English in Yale University.
8vo. Limp cloth, x + 36 pages. Mailing price, 35 cents ; for introduc-
tion, 30 cents.

rpHE study of what is essential and what accidental in poetry is
more and more engaging the attention of thoughtful men,
particularly those occupied with educational work. Newman's
Essay expresses the view of one who was a man of both action
and theory. Besides this, the Essay is a notable example of the
literary work of one who has been considered the greatest master
of style in this generation. The illustrative apparatus provided by
the editor includes practical hints on the study of Greek drama in
English, an index, an analysis, and a few suggestive notes.

Hiram Corson, Prof, of English,
Cornell University. In its editorial
character it's an elegant piece of
work. . . . The introduction is a

multum in parvo bit of writing ; and
the notes show the recherche scholar-
ship of the editor.


The Art of Poetry :

The Poetical Treatises of Horace, Vida, and Boileau, with the trans-
lations by Howes, Pitt, and Soame.

Edited by Albert S Cook, Professor of the English Language and
Literature in Yale University. 12mo. Cloth. 214 pages. Mailing
price, $1.25; for introduction, $1.12.

T^HIS volume is intended to meet the wants of three classes of
teachers and students, those of Latin, French, and English or
comparative literature. To the first class it will furnish the best
Latin metrical criticisms, ancient and modern, on poetry ; to the
second, a classic which every highly educated Frenchman is sup-
posed to know by heart ; and to the third, an authoritative state-
ment, by poets themselves, of the canons recognized in the
Augustan ages of Latin, Italian, and French literature, and, to a
very considerable extent, in the so-called Augustan period of
English literature, the reign of Queen Anne. Those who read
Latin and French will here find the originals, while those who
read only English are provided with standard translations. A
full index, containing lists of the Homeric and Virgilian passages
illustrated and a topical analysis of the threefold work enhance
its value for the class-room and the private student.

Bliss Perry, Prof, of English,
Williams College : The fullness and
accuracy of tlie references in the
notes is a testimony to his patience

as well as his scholarship. ... I
wish to express my admiration of
such faithful and competent editing.

Addison's Criticisms on Paradise Lost.

Edited by Albert S. Cook, Professor of the English Language and Lit-
erature in Yale University. 12mo. Cloth, xxvi + 200 pages. Mailing
price, $1.10; for introduction, $1.00.

HHHE text of this edition is based upon the literal reproductions
of Arber and Morley, and, allowing for the modernization of
spelling and punctuation, is believed to be more correct than any
published in this century. The index is unusually full, and will
enable Addison's comments on any particular passage of Paradise
Lost, as well as on those of the ancient epics with which it is
compared, to be found with the least possible trouble.

V. D. Scudder, Inst, in English
Literature, Wellesley College: It
seems to me admirably edited and to

be welcome as an addition to our
store of text-books.


' What is Poetry ? '

Leigh Hunt's An Answer to the Question including Remarks on

Edited by Albert S. Cook, Professor of the English Language and
Literature in Yale University. 12mo. Cloth. 104 pages. Mailing
price, 50 cents; for introduction, 60 cents.

r^NE of the most delightful short papers on the subject of
poetry is this of Leigh Hunt. Its definitions, its quotations,
and especially its charm and spirit make it peculiarly valuable
for school and college use as an intr'oductton to a course in poetry
or criticism. In this edition the quotations are conformed to the
best texts, which cannot always be said of the ordinary issues.
The notes are few and brief, and have, for convenience, been
relegated to the foot of the page ; in many cases they are merely
devoted to locating the quotations employed in the text, an aid
for which both teacher and student will be thankful. The index,
as in other books by the same editor, is a feature of the new

Analytics of Literature.

By L. A. Sherman, Professor of English Literature in the University
of Nebraska. 12mo. Cloth. 488 pages. Mailing price, 81.40; for
introduction, ,^1.25.

n^HIS book was written to embody a new system of teaching
literature that has been tried with great success. The chief
features of the system are the recognition of elements, and insuring
an experience of each, on the part of the learner, according to the
laboratory plan. The principal stages in the evolution of form
in literature are made especial subjects of study.

It aims to make criticism begin on less vague and more exact
foundations. The discussion in each chapter is in the nature of a
condensed lecture before laboratory experiment and verification in
the topic treated. The text-pages of the volume proper are adapted
alike to students of higher or lower gTade, and the treatment, so
far as left incomplete, is continued in notes provided in an appen-
dix. To aid teachers not acquainted with laboratory methods,
hints and suggestions how to set the student at work for himself
are added to many chapters.


Ben Jonson's Timber : or Discoveries ;

Made upon Men and Matter, as they have Flowed out of his Daily
Reading, or had their Reflux to his Peculiar Notions of the Times.

Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by Felix E. Schelling, Professor
in the University of Pennsylvania. 12mo. Cloth, xxxviii + 166 pages.
Mailing price, 90 cents ; for introduction, 80 cents.

^HIS is the first attempt to edit a long-neglected English classic,
which needs only to be better known to take its place among
the best examples of the height of Elizabethan prose. The text
— the restoration of which entitles the book to a place in every
library — is based on a careful collation of the folio of 1641 with
subsequent editions ; with such modernization in spelling and
punctuation as a conservative judgment has deemed imperative.
The introduction and a copious body of notes have been framed
with a view to the intelligent understanding of an author whose
wide learning and wealth of allusion make him the fittest exponent
of the scholarship as well as the literary style and feeling of his age.

Edward Dowden, Prof, of English,
Trinity College, Dublin, L^eland : It
is a matter for rejoicing that so valu-
able and interesting a piece of liter-

ature as this prose work of Jonson,
should be made easily accessible and
should have all the advantages of
scholarly editing.

A Primer of Englisii Verse.

By Hiram Corson, Professor of English Literature in Cornell Univer-
sity. 12mo. Cloth, iv + 232 pages." By mail, $1.10; for introduction,


n^HE leading purpose of this volume is to introduce the student
to the aesthetic and organic character of English Verse — to
cultivate his susceptibility to verse as an inseparable part of poetic
expression. To this end, the various effects provided for by the
poet, either consciously or unconsciously on his part, are given for
the student to practice upon, until those effects come out distinctly
to his feeling's.

The University Magazine, New
York : Prof. Corson has given us
a most interesting and thorough
treatise on the chai'acteristics and
uses of English metres. He dis-
cusses the force and effects of vari-

ous metres, giving examples of usage
from various i)oets. The book will
be of great use to both the critical
student and to those who recognize
that poetry, like music, is constructed
on scientific and precise principles.


Five Short Courses of Reading in English Litera-


With Biographical and Critical References. By C. T. Winchester,
Professor of English Literature in Wesleyan University. Sq. IGmo.
Cloth. V + 99 pages. Mailing price, 45 cents ; for introduction, 40 cents.

rpmS little book lays out five short courses of reading from the

most prominent writers in pure literature of the last three

centuries, beginning with Marlowe and ending with Tennyson.

The book contains also information as to the best editions for

student use, with extended and well chosen lists of critical and

biographical authorities.

Le Baron K. Briggs, Professor of
English, Harvard University : I am

much pleased with it. It cannot help
being useful.

Synopsis of English and American Literature.

By G. J. Smith, Instructor of English, Washington (D.C.) High School.
8vo. Cloth. 125 pages. By mail, 90 cents ; for introduction, 80 cents.

/^NE finds here in every case the author's full name, the dates
of birth and death, the class of writers to which he belongs,
the chronological place of that class in the development of litera-

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 20

Online LibraryFrancis Jeffrey JeffreySelections from the essays of Francis Jeffrey → online text (page 20 of 21)