Reports of cases adjudged and determined in the Supreme court of judicature and Court for the trial of impeachments and correction of errors of the state of New York (Volume 17) online

. Y. R, 17. 1



REPORTS OF CASES



ADJUDGED AND DETERMINED



IN THE



Supreme Court of Judicature



AND



COURT EOR THE TRIAL OP IMPEACHMENTS



AND



CORRECTION OF ERRORS



OP



THE STATE OF NEW YOEK

WITH COPIOUS NOTES AND REFERENCES, TABLES OF CITATIONS, &c.



BY

EDWIN BURRITT SMITH

AND

ERNEST HITCHCOCK,

COUNSELORS AT LAW.



BOOK



CONTAINING DENIO'S REPORTS, VOLUMES 2-5.



THE LAWYERS' CO-OPERATIVE PUBLISHING: COMPANY,
NEWARK, WAYNE COUNTY, NEW YORK.

' 1885.







Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year eighteen hundred and eighty-five, by

THE LAWYERS' CO-OPERATIVE PUBLISHING CO.,
In the Office of the Librarian of Congress, Washington, D. C.



E. R. Andrews, Printer, Rochester, N. Y.



JUDGES

OP THE

SUPREME COURT



DURING THE PERIOD OF THESE REPORTS.



GREENE C. BRONSON, Chief Justice.
SAMUEL BEARDSLEY,* Chief Justice.
SAMUEL BEARDSLEY,



Justices.
FREEBORN G. JEWETT,

FREDERICK WHITTLESEY,

Justices.}
THOMAS McKissocK,



CIRCUIT JUDGES.
First Circuit. Fifth Circuit.

JOHN W. EDMONDS. PHILO GRIDLEY.

Second Circuit. Sixth Circuit.

SEWARD BARCULO.:): HIRAM GRAY.

Third Circuit. Seventh Circuit^

AMASA J. PARKER. BOWEN WHITING.

Fourth Circuit. Eighth Circuit.

JOHN WILLARD. NATHAN DAYTON.

JOHN VAN BUREN, Attorney-General.
AMBROSE L. JORDAN, Attorney- General after Jan. 1, 1848 ',



JUDGES OF THE COURT OF APPEALS.



FREEBORN G. JEWETT, Chief Judge.
GREENE C. BRONSON, "I
ADDISON GARDINER, > Judges.

CHARLES H. RUGGLES, J
SAMUEL JONES, "]

WILLIAM B. WRIGHT, j Justices of the Supreme Court
> selected to sit in the Court
CHARLES GRAY, O f Appeals.

THOMAS A. JOHNSON,



* Appointed in place of Hon. Greene C. Bronson. elected a Judge of Court of Appeals.
t In places of Justice Beardsley, appointed Chief Justice, and Justice Jewett, elected Judge of Court
of Appeals.

$ Appointed April 4, 1846, in place of Hon. Charles H. Ruggles, resigned.



MEMBEES

OF THE

COURT FOR THE TRIAL OF IMPEACHMENTS

AND THE

CORRECTION OF ERRORS,

DURING THE TIME OP THE FOLLOWING REPORTS.



ADDISON GARDINER, President of the Senate.

REUBEN HYDE WALWORTH, Chancellor.

GREENE C. BRONSON, Ch. J. \

SAMUEL BEARDSLEY, > Justices of the Supreme Court.

FREEBORN G. JEWETT, '



SENATORS.

First District.

ISAAC L. VARIAN,' EDWARD SANFORD,*

-JOHN A. LOTT/ 2 DAVID R. FLOYD JONES,' *

GEORGE FOLSOM.' 2

Second District.

ABRAHAM BOCKEE,' SAXTON SMITH, 2

ABRAHAM A. DEYO, : 2 JOSHUA B. SMITH/ 9

ROBERT DENNISTON,' 2

Third District.

ERASTUS CORNING,' STEPHEN C. JOHNSON,' *

JOHN C. WRIGHT/ 2 JOHN P BEEKMAN,' 2

WILLIAM H. VAN ScnooNHOVEN. 2

Fourth District.

EDMUND VARNEY.' SAMUEL YOUNG,*

THOMAS B. MITCHELL,' * ORVILLE CLARK.' 2

AUGUSTUS C. HAND.' 2

Fifth District.

GEORGE C. SHERMAN,' JOSHUA A. SPENCER,*

CARLOS P. SCOVIL,' * THOMAL BARLOW.' s

ENOCH B. TALCOTT.' 2

Sixth District.

JAMES FAULKNER,' THOMAS J. WHEELER,' 2

CALVIN T. CHAMBERLAIN,' s CLARK BURNHAM,' 8

GEORGE D. BEERS.' *

Seventh District.

WILLIAM BARTLIT.' RICHARD H. WILLIAMS,*

JOHN PORTER,' 3 ALBERT LESTER,' 9

HENRY J. SEDGWICK,' s

Eighth District.

GIDEON HARD.' J FREDERICK F. BACKUS,' *

HARVEY PUTNAM, ' 2 CARLOS EMMONS.' *



1 Senators for 1845.
Senators for 1846.



GENERAL TABLE OF CASES REPORTED

IN THIS BOOK.



CASES REPORTED IN DENIO, VOL. II.



A


Dexter . Adams,


646




Q


Dowe . Schutt, -


621


ADOOll V. JL Obi,

Adams, Dexter v.


ou

646


Dunlap . Hunting, ....


643


Adams v. Hull, - - - - -


306


Dunn . Hewitt, -


637


Arnot, Post v.


344






Athearn, Elkins v. - - -


191


Edwards, Butts . - - - -


164


B




Elkins . Athearn,


191


Bailey, Mayor of N. Y. . -


433






Bailey, v. Wakeman, -
Baker v. Robbins, ....
Bank of Salina. Henry, ;
Barker v. Bucklin, ....
Beach . Gray,
Besly, Coville.


220
136
155
45
84
139


Ferguson, Brown .
Furguson, Foshay .
Ferris . Crawford, ....
Foshay . Ferguson, - - - -
Frost, Taylor v. - - - -


196
617
595
617
200


Bigelow, Harrington v.


109


G




Birckhead v. Brown, - - - -


375


Gable, Miller .


492


Bolmer, Taylor v.


193


Gale, Mead . -


232


Boughton, Buel v. - - - -
Boyd v. Weeks,


91
'321


Gale . Mead,
Getman, Broadwell, .


160

87


Boyer v. Pack,
Breed, Colegrove v.
Briggs, Supervisors of Onondaga Co. v.


107
125
26


Gifford . Livingston, ....
Glover. Whittenhall, -.-"
Gosman, Merritt .


380
633
186


Broadwell v. Getman, ....


87


Graves . McKeou, ....


639


Brown, Birkhead . - -


375


Gray, Beach . .....


84


Brown v. Ferguson,


196


Green, Whitcomb . -


113


Bucklin, Barker . - - - -
Buel v. Boughton,


45
91


Gregory . Stryker, -
Grout . Townsend,


628
336


Bull, Church v.


430






Bull v. Ketchum, -


188


H




Burdick v. McVanner, ....
Burghart v. Rice,
Butts v. Edwards, ....


170
95
164


Halsey, Sand ford .
Harger . McCullough,
Harrington . Bigelow, -


235
119
109


C




Heaney v. Heeney,


625


Cartledge. West, -
Chenango Co. Mut. Ins. Co., Jennings


377

75


Henry, Bank of Salina .
Hewitt, Dunn . -
Hodges . City of Buffalo, -


155
637
110


Church . Bull,
Churchill, Rice v. . " - , -
City of Buffalo, Hodges v.


430
145
110


Hull, Adams .
Hunting, Dunlap.
Hymann . Cook, - - - -


306
643
201


Clark v. Rawson,


135


J




Coffee. Lawrence,
Colegrove. Breed, -' - * - " M
Colville . Besly,
Com. Bank of Buffalo . Sparrow,


195
125
139
97


James . Woodruff, -
Jennings . Chenango Co. Mut. Ins. Co.,
Johnston, Conger *. - -
Jordan, Macy . -


574

75
96
570


Conger . Johnston, ....
Cook, Hymann .


96

201


Judges N. Y. C. P., People .


197


Cooper, Stone .


293


K




Cornell . Todd,


130


Kellogg . Schuyler, -


73


Costigan v. Mohawk & H. R. R. Co.,


609


Kelly, Striker .


323


Crandall "Vanderhevden .


g


T7" * V* "D 11


188


Crawford Ferris .


595




341


Curtis . Knox


341




368


Cushman, Robinson .


149


L




D




Lawrence, Coffee .


195


Davis, Turner .


187


Lawrence . Trustees of the L. & W.




Denny . Manhattan Co., ...


115


Orphan House, ....


577


DENIO 2.




7



CASES REPOKTED.



Lewis, Munsell v.

Livingston, Gifford v.

Livingston, Matter of -

Loubat, Wallis v. - - - -

M

McCullough, Harger .
McFarland, Wheeler . - - -
McKeon, Graves .-
McVanner, Burdick .
Macy t>. Jordan, -
Manhattan Co., Denny v.
Martin, Stone v. -
Mather v. Perry, -
Mayor of N. Y. v. Bailey, -
Mayor of N. Y., Russell v.
Mead, Gale v. ....

Mead v. Gale,

Merritt v. Gosman,

Miller v. Gable, -

Miller, Wheeler .'-

Mohawk & H. R. R. Co., Costigan v.

Mosher, Roseboom v. -

Munsell . Lewis, -



Pack, Boyer v. -

People v. Judges of N. Y. C. P.,

People 0. Stowell,

People, Warner v. - -

Perry, Mather v. -

Philbrick, Shepard .

Post V. Arnot, -

R

Rawson, Clark v.
Rice, Burghart v. -
Rice v. Churchill,
Robbins, Baker v.
Robinson v. Cushman,
Roseboom v. Mosher, -
Russell v. Mayor of N. Y.,



S



Sandford v. Halsey,
Schutt, Dowe v.



224


Schuyler, Kellogg . - -


73


380


Shearman, Webber v.


362


575


Shepard v. Philbrick, - ...


174


607


Smith, Thompson v.


177




Sparrow, Com. Bank of Buffalo v.


97




Stewart r>. Trustees of Ham. College,


403


119


Stone v. Cooper,


293


183


Stone v. Martin,


185


639


Stowell, People . - -


127


170


Striker . Kelly,


323


570


Stryker, Gregory v. - - - -


628


115

185
162


Supervisors of Onondaga Co. v. Briggs, -
Suydam . Westfall, ....


26

205


433


T




461


Taylor v. Bolmer,


193


160


Taylor v. Frost,


200


232


Thompson . Smith, -


177


186


Todd, Cornell v. -


180


492


Townsend, Grout v.


336


172


Trustees of Ham. College, Stewart v. -


403


609


Trustees of L. & W. Orphan House,




61




*577


224




187




V


1O I


107
197


Vanderheyden v. Crandall, - '-


9


127


W




272
ic.>


Wakeman, Bailey . - -


220


1WB


Wallis v. Loubat, -


607


9AA.


Warner v. People, -


272


Orttt


Webber v. Shearman, -


362




Weeks, Boyd v.


321


135


West, Cartledge v.


377


95


Westfall, Suydam . - -


205


145


Wheeler v. McFarland,


183


186


Wheeler v. Miller,


172


149


Whitcomb v. Green, ....


113


61


Whittenhall, Glover v.


633


461


Wolff v. Koppel,


368




Woodruff, James v.


574


235


Y




621


Yost, Abbott v.


86



CASES REPORTED IN DENIO, VOL. III.



Abbot, Bank of Salina . -
Ablon, Hargous v.
Adams, People v.
Adams, Walsh v, -
Albany Ins. Co., Howard v.
Alexanders. Carpenter,
Allen v. Culver,
Anstice v. Holmes,
Areson, Areson v. -
Areson v. Areson, -
Argall v. Smith,

B

Baker, Courtney v.
Baker, Rich v.
Bank of Salina, Henry v.
Bank of Salina v. Abbot,
Beardsley v. Dygert, -
Becker, Keenholts v.
8



- 181
406

190, 610
125

- 801
266

- -284

244

- 458
458

- 435



27

- 79
593

- 181
380

- 346



Beers, Swift v. - -

Bennett, Ex parte,

Blanchard v. Nestle, ...

Blunt v. McCormick, - - -

Bouchard . Bias,

Bouchard. Dias v.

Bower . Tiermann, ...

Boyd, Manuf. & Merch. Bank of

Northern Liberties v. -
Bradley, Van Rensslaer v. - -
Bradley v. Burwell, - - -
Brady, McCosker v.
Briggs, Peck .
Briggs, Smith V.

Briggs, Supervisors of Onondaga v.
Brown, Wilbur v.
Bryan, Ruckman . - -
Bunn, McDonald. - -
Burckle v. Eckart, - -
Burwell, Bradley v. - -



- 70

175
. 37

- 283
238"
610

. 373
the

- 257

- 135

- 61, 261

610

107

73

- 173
356

- 340

- 45

- 279
61, 261

3.



GASES REPORTED.



C

Carpenter, Alexander v. -
Catnell, Platt v. - - - -
Chamberlin v. Griggs,
Charles, People v.
Charter v, Stevens, -
Church, Kellogg. -
Churchill v. Hunt,
Clark, matter of, -
Clark v. Denure,
Clute, Clute v. - - - *

Clute v. Clute,

Coddington v. Davis, -

Cohen, Cusick v. - - - -

Conover v. Mut. Ins. Co. of Albany

Cook v. McDoel, ....

Cooke, Washburn v.

Coons, Norton v. - - - -

Cornell v. Moulton, - - .

Corning v. McCullough, - - -

Courtney v. Baker,

Culver, Allen v.

Currin v. Finn, -

Curtis v. Jones, -

Cusick v. Cohen, -

D

Danks . Quackenbush,

Davis, Coddington v.

Delamater v. Pierce, - -

Denure, Clark . - -

Devendorf , Weaver v.

Dias, Bouchard v. -

Dias v. Bouchard, ...

Doremus v. Kinney, ...

Dormedy, Kanouse v. -

Doughty v. Hope, ....

Dygert, Beardsley v. -



Earl v. Spooner,
Eckart, Burckle v.



E



F



- 266

604

9

212, 610

- 33
228

- 321
167

- 319
263

- 263
16, 610

- 267
254

- 317
110

- 130

12

- 589

27

- 284
229

- 590
267



594

16, 610
315, 610

- 319
117

- 238
610

- 178
567

249, 594
380



246
279



Fellows v. Prentiss, -

Finn, Currin v.

First Ref. Protestant D. Ch., Phelps v.

Fowler v. Starr,

Frazer v. Western, - - - -
Freeland, Gracie v. -



G



Gallup, Hodge v.
Gardner . Heartt,
Garrett v. Scouten, -
Gracie v. Freeland,
Graves . McKeon, -
Griffith v. Wells, -
Griggs, Chamberlin v.
Grosvenor v. Rogers, -

H

Hadden, People v. -
Hall, Whitmarsh v.
Halstead, Spencer v.
Harbeck, Willard v. -
Hargous v. Ablon, -
Harris, Van Valkenburgh v.
Hayes, Stone v.
Healey, Williams v.
Heartt, Gardner v. -
Henderson, Henderson v.
Henderson v. Henderson,
DENIO 3.



512
229
264
164
610
609



527
232
334
609
610
226
9
267



220
375
610
260
406
162
575
363
232
314
314



Henry . Bank of Salina,
Henschel v. Mahler, -
Herter v. La Farge,
Hodge v. Gallup,
Hoes v. Van Hoesen, -
Holmes, Anstice v. -
Honeyman, People t>. -
Hope, Doughty v.
Howard, Sibley v.
Howard v. Albany Ins. Co.
Hunt, Churchill v. *
Hunt, Stocking v. -



Jackson, People v. ' -. .
Jenkins, Wooster v.
Jenks v. Smith, -
Jermaine, Waggoner v. ,-
Jones, Curtis v. -
Johnston, Van Keuren v.



K



Kanouse v. Dormedy,
Kast v. Kathern,
Kathern, Kast v. -
Keenholts v. Becker,
Kellogg v. Church,
Kinney, Doremus v.



593

- 428
157

- 527
610

- 244
121

249, 594
72

- 301
321

- 274



101
187
592
306
590
183



567
344
344
346

228
178



Ladue, Nevin v. 43, 437

La Farge v. Herter, 157

Langworthy, Marchant v. - - - 526

Lansing, Slocum v. 259

Larkin, Williams v. - - - - 114

Lewis v. Miner, 103

Luer, Waydell v. -' - - - 410

M

McCormick, Blunt v. - - - - 283

McCosker v. Brady, 610

McCullough, Corning v. - - - - 589

McDoel, Cook v. - - - - - 317

McDonald 0. Bunn, 45

McFarlan, Ulster Co. Bank v. - - 553

McKeon, Graves v. 610

McKeon v. Whitney, - 452

Mahler, Henschel v. - - - - 428
Manuf. & Merch. Bank of the Northern

Liberties v. Boyd, - - - - 257

Marchant v. Langworthy, - - - 526

Marvin v. Richmond, 58

Mathewson v. Weller, - 52

Menck, Partridge v. - - - - 610

Miles v. Pulver, 84

Milliken v. Selye, 54

Millius v. Shafer, 60

Miner, Lewis v. 103

Mitchell, Moehring v. - - - - 610

Moehring v. Mitchell, .... 610

Morris v. People, 381

Mott, Postley v. - 353

Moulton, Cornell v. - - 12

Mut. Ins. Co. of Albany, Conover v. - 254



N



Nestle, Blanchard v.
Nevin v. Ladue,
Norton v. Coons, -



Partridge v. Menck,
Payne, People v. -



37

43, 437
130



610

88

J



CASES REPORTED.



Peck . Briggs, ....
Pierce, Delamater v.
People v. Adams, - - - -
People v. Charles, -
People v. Hadden, -
People. Honeyman,
People v. Jackson, ...
People, Morris v. - - -
People v. Payne, - ' * -
People v. Taylor,
Phelps v. First Ref. Protestant D
Platt, Rice v.
Platt . Cathell, ' -
Postley v. Mott, -
Prentiss, Fellows v.
Priest, Regan . - -
Pulver, Miles v. - -


Q

Quackenbush, Danks v.



R



Raynor, Shove v.
Regan v. Priest, -
Rice v. Platt, -
Rich 0. Baker,
Richmond, Marvin v.
Robertson v. Sheill,
Rogers, Grosvernor v.
Rowe, Stevens v. -
Ruckman v. Bryan, -

S

Saltus, Simersfl. -
Sandford v. Sinclair,
Schoonmaker v. Sheely,
Scouten, Garrett v. -
Selye, Milliken v. -
Shafer, Millius v.
Sheely, Schoonmaker v.
Sheill, Robertson v.
Sherman, Whiley v.
Shove v. Raynor,
Shufelt, Whitney v. -
Sibley v. Howard, -
Simers v. Saltus, -
Sinclair, Sandford v.
Slocum v. Lansing,
Smith, Argall v.
Smith, Jenks v.
Smith v. Briggs,
Snyder, Taylor v. -
Spear v. Wardell,



107

- 315, 610
190, 610

- 212, 610

220

- 121
101

- 381

88

91, 99

Ch. - 264

81

- 604
353

- 512
163

- 84



594



77

163

81

79

58

161

267

327

340



214
269
485
334

54

60
485
161
185

77
165

72
214
269
259
435
592

73
145
607



Spencer t>. Halstead, - - - - ' 610

Spooner, Earl v. 246

Starr, Fowler v. 154

Stevens, Charter v. 33

Stevens v. Rowe, 327

Stevens v. Wilson, ..... 473

Stocking v. Hunt, .... 374

Stone . Hayes, 575

Supervisors of Onondaga . Briggs, - 173

Swift v. Beers, 70



Taylor, People v. - - - - 91, 99

Taylor v. Snyder, 145

Thompson v. Valarino, - - - 179

Tiermann, Bower v. 373
Trustees of Wilson Collegiate Inst. .

Van Home, 171

U

Ulster County Bank v. McFarlan, .- - 553



Valarino, Thompson v. 179
Van Hoesen, Hoes v. 610
Van Home, Trustees of Wilson Collegi-
ate Inst. v.- 171

Van Keuren v. Johnston, - - 183

Van Rensselaer v. Bradley, - - - 135

Van Valkenburgh v. Harris, - - - 162

W

Waggoner v. Jermaine, ... 306

Walsh v. Adams , 125

Wardell, Spear v. 607

Washburn v. Cooke, - - - - 110

Washburn, Woodward v. - - - 369

Waydell v. Luer, 410

Weaver v. Devendorf, - - - - 117

Weller, Mathewson . - - - 52

Wells, Griffith v. 226

Western, Frazer v. 610

Whiley v. Sherman, - ... 185

Whitmarsh v. Hall, 375

Whitney, McKeon v. - - - 452

Whitney v. Shufelt, - - - - 165

Wilbur v. Brown, .... 356

Willard v. Harbeck, - - - - 260

Williams v. Healey, .... 363

Williams v. Larkin, .... 114

Wilson, Stevens v. - - - - 472

Woodward v. Washburn, - - - 369

Wooster v. Jenkins, .... 187



CASES REPORTED IN DENIO, VOL. IV.



Abbott v. Draper,

Abell v. Douglass,

Ackerman v. Vail, - - .

Ahrenfeldt, Stewart, v.

Ainslie, Stinemets v.

Alden, Wynn . -

Alexander v. Taylor,

Allaire, Whitney v.

American Ins. Co. of N. Y., Gordon v.

Arnold D. Maltby,

10



Arnot v. McClure, -




- 41


- 51

OACT


Ashley, Corning v.
Auburn & Owasco C.


Co. v. Leitch,


354
- 65


o05

OAT


Austin v. Daniels,


...


299


- <J97
189


Averill v. Williams, -


.


- 295


- 573




B




163


Babcock v. Peck,


.


- 292


- 302


Bailey v. Mogg, -


.


60


554


Baker . Thrasher, -


.


- 493


D. - 360


Bame v. Drew,


...


287


498


Bank of Rochester v.


Jones, -


- 489






DENIO 4.



CASES REPORTED.



Barnes, Heely v. - - - - - "
Barton, Tifft 9. - - - - -
Beach, Scribner 9.
Beal, Payn v. - - - -
Bennett v. Pratt, - - - - *

Belts, Wilson v.

Bigelow v. Heaton,

Bliven, Van Alen . - -
Blowers*. Sturtevant, ....
Bogert, Morse v. - - - - ' >

Boice v. Main,

Bokee, Bruen v. - - -

Brice, Sammis v.

Brinkerhoff, Miller v. - - -
Brisbane . Pratt, - - - - -
Brooks, People v. - - - -
Bruen v. Bokee, - - - - .
Buckley v. Leonard, - - : +

Buell, Schermerhorn v. - - - -

Burns, Monell v.

Burt, Sizer v.

Butler v. People,

C

Caryl, Lamoure v. - - - ; ""

Chase, Flinn v.

Chautauqua Co. Bank v. Risley,
City Fire Ins. Co., Howard v.
Clark, Shipman V.
Clarke v. Dunham, ... -

Clement, Wilcox v.

Clute, Clute v.

Clute v. Clute,

Conly, Palmer, v. - - - -

Cooper, Stebbins v.

Coope, Stilwell v.

Cope v. Gilbert,

Corning v. Ashley, ....

Covill v. Hill.

Crane, Warnick . - -

Crissie, People v.

Cunningham v. Goelet, - - -

D

Daniels, Austin t>.

Day, Wait v.

Del and v. Richardson, - -

Delaware & H. C. Co. v. Westchester Co.

Bank,

Dewey v. Greene,

Deyo 9. Stewart,

Dickinson, Fenno v. - -

Dike v. Lewis,

Dodge, Fish v.

Dodge, Sheldon v.

Dodge, Worden . - -

Douglass, Abell v.

Draper, Abbott v. - -

Drew, Bamefl.

Duel v. Fisher,

Dull v. People,

Dumont v. Smith,

Dunham, Clarke v. - - - >



Elwood, Piper v.
Erwin, People 9. -



Fairchild, Gillet v.
Fanning v. Farley,
Farley, Fanning v.
DENIO 4.



E



F



73
171
448
405
275
201
496
455

46
108

55

56
576
118

63
469

56
500
422
121
426



370
85
480
502
446
262
160
241
241
374
191
225
347
354
323
460
525
71



299

439

95



93
101

84
237
311
217
159
305

51
287
515

91
319
262



165
129



80
263
263



Fenno . Dickinson, - - -' .

Fish v. Dodge,

Fisher, Duel v.

Fleming, People v. -

Flinn v. Chase,

Freeman v. People, - - - -
Funck, Merian .

G

Gilbert, Cope v.

Gillet v. Fairchild, ....

Goelet, Cunningham .

Gordon v. American Ins. Co. of N. Y. ,

Greene, Dewey v. -

Greenleaf v. Low, - ...

Guild, People t>. - - - . - .

Guion, Marshall v. -

H

Hamer . McFarlin, -,

Harris, People v. - - . -
Hawley, Mitchell v. -.'''-.
Hayes, Norton t>. - - - -
Heath, Taylor. - - - - -
Heaton, Bigelow v. ... -

Heely v. Barnes,

Hill, Covill 9.

Hitchcock, Whitney v.
Hodgman 9. People,
Hogeboom, Rich . - -
Hooker 9. Vandewater, -
Howard 9. City Fire Ins. Co. ,
Rowland, More v. - - - .
Hewlett, Staats . - -
Hulbut, People 9. ....

Hull, Miller .

Humphrey, Simsv. - - - -

Hurd v. Swan,

Huxford, Palmerton 9. - - -



Johnson v. People,

Jones, Bank of Rochester 9.



Kane, People . - -
Keeling, Trustees of Clintonville, v.



Lake v. Trustees of Williamsburgh,
Lamoure v. Caryl, - - - -
Lawrence, Mosher v. -

Lee v. Parry,

Leitch, Auburn & Owasco C. 9.

Leonard, Buckley o.

Lewis, Dike 9.

Lewis, Thayer 9.

Loomis, People 9. - -

Low, Greenleaf 9, -

Lyke v. Van Leuven, -

Lynch v. Stone, -

M

McClure, Arnot 9. -

McCoon, Silsbury. - - -

McFarlan 9. Triton Ins. Co., - -

McFarlan, Hamer .

McKay, Hosier 9. - - - -

McKeon, Peters . - - -

Main, Boice 9.

Maltby, Arnold 9.

Manning, Palmer 9. - - - -



84
311
515
137

85

9

110



347

80

71

360

93

168

551

581



509
150
414
245
592
496

73
323
461
235
453
349
502
264
559
133
104
185

75
166



364

489



530
341



520
370
419
125
65
500
237
269
380
168
127
356



41
332
392
509
116
546

55
498
131

11



CASES REPOKTED.



Mapes, Winfield v.
Marsh, Stearns .
Marshall . Guion,
Merrian, Exparte
Merrian . Funck,
Miller . Brinkerhoff,
Miller v. Hull,
Mitchell, Sherwood v.
Mitchell v. Hawley,
Mogg, Bailey v.
Monell v. Burns, -
Moody. Pomeroy, -
Moores, People v. -
More. Rowland, -
Morse t>. Bogart, -
Mosher v. Lawrence,
Mosier v. McKay, -



Nellis v. Turner,
Newcomb, Stevens v.
Nicoll v. Walworth,
Niles v. Stevens, -
Norton v. Hayes,



O



Orcutt v. Pettit,



Palmer v. Conly,
Palmer v. Manning,
Palmerton . Huxford, -
Parish, People v.
Parry, Lee v. -
Payn v. Beal, - - /
Peck, Babcock v.
People v. Brooks, -
People, Butler v.
People v. Crissie, -
People, Dull v.
People . Erwin, - - -
People v. Fleming,
People, Freeman v.
People v. Guild,
People v. Harris, -
People, Hodgman .
People v. Hulbut,
People, Johnson v. -
People v. Kane, -
People . Loomis, -
People v. Moores.
People v. Parish, ...
People . Ransom,
People v. Supers, of Ontario, -
Peters v. McKeon,
Pettit, Orcutt v.
Piper v. Elwood, -
Pomeroy, Moody v. -
Pratt, Bennett B.-
Pratt, Brisbane v.

R

Randall v. Wilkins, -
Ransom, People. ...
Rich v. Hogeboom,
Richardson, Deland v.
Risley. Chautauqua Co. Bank v.



Sammis v. Brice,
12



571
227
581
254
110
118
104
435
414
60
121
115
518
264
108
419
116



553
437
385
399
245



233



374
181
166
153
125
405
292
469

68
525

91

129

137

9

551
150
235
133
364
530
380
518
153
145
260
546
233
165
115
275

63



577
145
453
95
480



576



Schermerhorn v. Buell, -
Scribner v. Beach,
Sheldon v. Dodge, ..
Sherwood v. Mitchell, .
Shipman v. Clark, ..
Shumway, Exparte
Silsbury . McCoon, ..
Sims v. Humphrey,
Sizer v. Burt,

Sleeper c.Van Middlesworth,
Smith, Dumont v. - -
Staats v. Hewlett,
Stafford v. Williams, - -
Stearns v. Marsh,
Stebbins v. Cooper, ..
Stevens v. Newcomb, .
Stevens, Niles v.
Stevenson, White v.
Stewart v. Ahrenfeldt, .
Stewart, Deyoc.
Stilwell . Coope,
Stiuemets v. Ainslie, .
Stone, Lynch v.
Sturtevant, Blowers v.
Supers, of Ontario, People .
Swan, Hurd v.



Taylor, Alexander v. - - ~

Taylor v. Heath,

Thayer v. Lewis,

Thayer v. Wright,

Thrasher, Baker v.

Tifft v. Barton, - - - -

Tifft, Tifft v.

Tifft v. Tifft,

Triton Ins. Co., McFarlan v. -

Truax, Vandenburgh v. - - -

Trustees of Clintonville v. Keeling,

Trustees of Williamsburgh, Lake v.

Turner, Nellis v.



Vail, Ackerman v.

Van Alen v. Bliven, ...

Vandenburgh v. Traux, - -

Vanderveer, Matter of - - -

Vandewater, Hooker v.

Van Leuven, Lyke . - - -

Van Middlesworth, Sleeper v. -

W

Wait v. Day,

Walworth, Nicoll v. - . -
Warnick v. Crane, -
Westchester Co. Bank, Delaware &

Co. v.

White v. Stevenson, - - -
Whitney. Allaire, ...
Whitney v. Hitchcock, - ..
Wilber, Woolley v.
Wilcox v. Clement,
Wilkins, Randall v.
Williams, Averill v. ...
Williams, matter of, - - -
Williams, Stafford v. - - -
Wilson v. Belts,
Winfield . Mapes,
Woolley . Wilber,
Worden . Dodge,
Wright. Thayer v. - - -
Wynn. Alden,



H. C.



422
443
317
435
445

258
333

185
426
431
319
559
182
227
191
437
399
193
139

101
225
573

356
46

260
75



302
592
269
180
493
171
175
175
392
464
341
520
553



297
455

464
249
349
127
431



439

385
460

97
193
554
461
570
160
577
295
194
182
201
571
570
159
180



DBNIO 4.



CASES REPORTED IN DENIO, VOL. V.



Aldrich, O'Dougherty t>. -
Allen, People v. -
Allen, Stanton v.
Alter, Rue v.
Artcher . Douglass,
Armstrong . Munday,
Averil, Gillett v.



Baker, Olyphant v. -
Barker, Leonard v.
Bell, Osborn v. -
Benedict v. Lansing,
Belts, Meyers v.
Birdseye, Ray v.
Black, Post v. -
Blair, Duncan v. -
Bloomer, Burroughs v.
Bloomingdale, De Freest ,
Bronson, Richmond v.
Brown, Lord v.
Brown v. Sprague, -
Brownell v. McEwen,
Browning . Hanford,
Budd, Herrington v.
Burch, Fort v. -
Burling, Seacord v.
Burroughs v. Bloomer,
Butler v. Miller,



Camp v. Chamberlain, -

Camp v. Morse,

Camp v. Pulver,

Canal Comrs. , People v. -

Chamberlain, Camp v.